Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Renaming toggle to toggleVisibility because it was conflicting with sidebar and breaking it #7855

Merged
merged 4 commits into from
Mar 2, 2017

Conversation

aghassemi
Copy link
Contributor

@aghassemi aghassemi commented Mar 1, 2017

Sidebar registers an action named toggle therefore we can not register toggle as a global action and not break backward compatibility. Renaming to toggleVisibility

/to @alanorozco
/cc @muxin Needs to be merged before Canary Cut

@aghassemi aghassemi requested a review from alanorozco March 1, 2017 09:34
@aghassemi aghassemi changed the title Renaming toggle to toggleVisibility because it was conflicting with s… Renaming toggle to toggleVisibility because it was conflicting with sidebar and breaking it Mar 1, 2017
@aghassemi aghassemi requested a review from dvoytenko March 1, 2017 16:44
@aghassemi
Copy link
Contributor Author

@dvoytenko

@alanorozco
Copy link
Member

Could we potentially consider an implementation that allows elements to override a global action?

@aghassemi
Copy link
Contributor Author

@alanorozco that's a good idea. let me see if I can implement that approach instead.

@aghassemi
Copy link
Contributor Author

@alanorozco @dvoytenko Alright I tried to provide a way for elements to override global actions that work in 99.9% of the cases but has a race condition that is not acceptable IMO. Details and implementation in this PR: #7912

Having a feature to allow overriding global actions by elements aside, I still like to proceed with this PR for a different reason:

Although toggle is a nice symmetric name to complement hide and show, it is still too generic and its meaning is derived based on the element it is acting on. For instance, it makes a lot of sense to add a toggle function to accordion to toggle between expanded/collapsed states, but that nothing to do with toggling visibility. So toggleVisibility as the global action is more clear and explicit.

@alanorozco
Copy link
Member

@aghassemi Makes sense.

@aghassemi aghassemi merged commit 919f802 into ampproject:master Mar 2, 2017
@dvoytenko
Copy link
Contributor

@aghassemi @alanorozco I think in reality, the risk condition would be triggered much more often. It'd be nice, I agree. But since we can't know whether or not the element overrides an action until it was fully downloaded, this might be too prohibitive.

erwinmombay pushed a commit that referenced this pull request Mar 9, 2017
* initial setup for extension nexxtv-player

* added nexxtv player logic

* nexxtv player bugfixes, cleanup, tests, docs

* added video interface, changed attribute start to seek-to

* reworked video interface for nexxtv-player

* added message handler for nexxtv player and tests

* nexxtv player minor fixes & cleanup

* nexxtv player changed indents from 4 spaces to 2

* added unlayoutCallback for nexxtv player

* initial setup for extension nexxtv-player

* added nexxtv player logic

* nexxtv player bugfixes, cleanup, tests, docs

* added video interface, changed attribute start to seek-to

* reworked video interface for nexxtv-player

* added message handler for nexxtv player and tests

* nexxtv player minor fixes & cleanup

* nexxtv player changed indents from 4 spaces to 2

* added unlayoutCallback for nexxtv player

* fixed linting issues (#7673)

* initial setup for extension nexxtv-player

* added nexxtv player logic

* nexxtv player bugfixes, cleanup, tests, docs

* added video interface, changed attribute start to seek-to

* reworked video interface for nexxtv-player

* added message handler for nexxtv player and tests

* nexxtv player minor fixes & cleanup

* nexxtv player changed indents from 4 spaces to 2

* added unlayoutCallback for nexxtv player

* initial setup for extension nexxtv-player

* added nexxtv player logic

* nexxtv player bugfixes, cleanup, tests, docs

* added video interface, changed attribute start to seek-to

* reworked video interface for nexxtv-player

* added message handler for nexxtv player and tests

* nexxtv player minor fixes & cleanup

* fixed linting issues (#7673)

* nexxtv player review fixes (#7816)

* nexxtv player: updated validation rules (#7816)

* nexxtv player validator ordered alphabetical, changed spec_url

* fire amp-dom-update event on insert and replace (#7819)

* temp

* trigger `amp-dom-update` event on insert and replace

* switch -amp-form to i-amp-form

* Validator Rollup (#7844)

* Revision bump.

* Revision bump for amp-playbuzz changes in #7450

* Revision bump.

* Allow filtering by HtmlFormat (AMP, AMP4ADS) in the code generator.

* Revision bump.

* Revision bump due to Github pull.

* Code generation now driven by a variable LIGHT, which is broader than the previous GENERATE_DETAILED_ERRORS distinction. LIGHT implies filtered for specific format (AMP or AMP4ADS, and only amp.validator.validateSaxEvents, and no detailed errors.

* Generate ValidatorRules.directAttrLists and globalAttrs and ampLayoutAttrs, reducing overhead by indirection.

* Implement parallax effect extension (#7794)

* Do not set hidden attribute on hide/collapse (#7879)

* amp-bind: Support `Math` functions (#7797)

* initial commit for Math in amp-bind

* fix lint

* ali's comment

* avoid scope conflicts with built-in functions

* remove Math functions from documentation

* Measure 3P ad latency (#7902)

* Update spec URLs from github to ampproject. (#7901)

* Update github urls to ampproject urls

* test .out updated

* Too many slashes.

* Moved Developing.md and Design_Principles.md (#7908)

* Rename DEVELOPING.md to contributing/DEVELOPING.md

* Move files to new folder

* Renaming toggle to toggleVisibility because it was conflicting with sidebar and breaking it (#7855)

* disable scrollRestoration auto for embed case (#7899)

* Disable Fast Fetch for all ads when remote.html is used. (#7906)

* Fix DoubleClick Fast Fetch bugs around categoryExclusions and tagForChildDirectedTreatment (#7843)

* Fix incorrect parameter name for `tagForChildDirectedTreatment` in DoubleClick.

* Added unit test for tagForChildDirectedTreatment.

* Fixed the categoryExclusions bug in Fast Fetch DoubleClick.

* Removed parens in arrow functions to satisfy linter

* Adds two new experiment IDs (#7850)

* Adds two new experiment IDs to distinguish "any externally triggered" experiment from "any internally triggered".

Also updates tests to remove a number of assumptions that only a single eid will be populated.

* Use return val to detect "externally selected"; test updates.

* Updated network implementation guide. (#7862)

* Updated network impl guide.

* Changed 'validation' to 'verification'

* Cid timeout error should not be dev error (#7911)

* Fix amp-ad test (#7918)

* Update amp-install-serviceworker.md (#7932)

Fully escape javascript regex.

* Update amp-cache-modifications.md (#7933)

Add `data-no-service-worker-fallback-shell-url` as a URL to be rewritten as absolute.

* amp-fx-parallax Don't use global (#7942)

* Viewer integration: rewrite error message to indicate request name (#7923)

* rewrite error message

* update

* ticks

* Fix up links in DEVELOPING.md (#7944)

We moved DEVELOPING.md to the contributing folder but didn't update many of the relative links accordingly.

* Popin ad extension document updated. (#7674)

* Add popin ad extension.

* register popin.

* Add resizeable attribute.

* Remove resizable.

* Implemented the render-start and no-content APIs.

* Fixed lint.

* Remove quatation.

* Use tei@popin.cc

* Rebase old commit .

* Fixed document because tag was not closed.

* I replaced the removed double quotes.

* Add double quotes.

* Support for bind expressions in mustache templates (#7602)

* first pass at adding/removing subtrees

* tests passing

* Add ability to add and remove bindings in the subtree rooted at a specific node

* lint fixes

* merge conflict

* ci issues

* some cleanup

* pr comments

* pr comments, new method of removing bindings for node and its children

* fix some lint warnings

* test and lint fixes

* mutation observer

* update comments

* add observer

* naive implementation

* cleanup

* clean

* cleanup bind impl

* very simple example of bind in a template

* pr comments

* lint errors

* pr comments

* cleanup

* lint errors

* pr comments

* pr comments and lint warnings

* typo

* comments

* more lint warnings

* pr comment

* change README

* cleanup

* pr comments

* pr comments 2

* lint warnings

* don't use foreach on Nodelist

* casting

* more ci warnings

* even more ci warnings

* even more ci warnings

* even more ci issues

* even more ci comments

* even more ci issues

* pr comments

* more pr comments

* fix refactoring oversight

* pr comments

* pr comments

* merge

* pr comments

* ci issues

* pr comments

* assertElement

* pr comments

* typo

* updating sanitizer

* fixing up sanitizer test

* pr comments

* pr comments

* expanded on amp-mustache tests

* pr comments

* remove class from whitelist

* restore whole sandbox

* update mustache validator test and output

* pr comments

* nexxtv player gulp check-types fixes (#7816)

* nexxtv player fix error gulp presumbit with postmessage (#7816)

* added dependency check for nexxtv player (#7816)

* nexxtv player minor fix in validator (#7816)

* nexxtv player fixed validator (#7816)

* fixed validator (#7816)
kmh287 pushed a commit to kmh287/amphtml that referenced this pull request Mar 13, 2017
kmh287 pushed a commit to kmh287/amphtml that referenced this pull request Mar 13, 2017
* initial setup for extension nexxtv-player

* added nexxtv player logic

* nexxtv player bugfixes, cleanup, tests, docs

* added video interface, changed attribute start to seek-to

* reworked video interface for nexxtv-player

* added message handler for nexxtv player and tests

* nexxtv player minor fixes & cleanup

* nexxtv player changed indents from 4 spaces to 2

* added unlayoutCallback for nexxtv player

* initial setup for extension nexxtv-player

* added nexxtv player logic

* nexxtv player bugfixes, cleanup, tests, docs

* added video interface, changed attribute start to seek-to

* reworked video interface for nexxtv-player

* added message handler for nexxtv player and tests

* nexxtv player minor fixes & cleanup

* nexxtv player changed indents from 4 spaces to 2

* added unlayoutCallback for nexxtv player

* fixed linting issues (ampproject#7673)

* initial setup for extension nexxtv-player

* added nexxtv player logic

* nexxtv player bugfixes, cleanup, tests, docs

* added video interface, changed attribute start to seek-to

* reworked video interface for nexxtv-player

* added message handler for nexxtv player and tests

* nexxtv player minor fixes & cleanup

* nexxtv player changed indents from 4 spaces to 2

* added unlayoutCallback for nexxtv player

* initial setup for extension nexxtv-player

* added nexxtv player logic

* nexxtv player bugfixes, cleanup, tests, docs

* added video interface, changed attribute start to seek-to

* reworked video interface for nexxtv-player

* added message handler for nexxtv player and tests

* nexxtv player minor fixes & cleanup

* fixed linting issues (ampproject#7673)

* nexxtv player review fixes (ampproject#7816)

* nexxtv player: updated validation rules (ampproject#7816)

* nexxtv player validator ordered alphabetical, changed spec_url

* fire amp-dom-update event on insert and replace (ampproject#7819)

* temp

* trigger `amp-dom-update` event on insert and replace

* switch -amp-form to i-amp-form

* Validator Rollup (ampproject#7844)

* Revision bump.

* Revision bump for amp-playbuzz changes in ampproject#7450

* Revision bump.

* Allow filtering by HtmlFormat (AMP, AMP4ADS) in the code generator.

* Revision bump.

* Revision bump due to Github pull.

* Code generation now driven by a variable LIGHT, which is broader than the previous GENERATE_DETAILED_ERRORS distinction. LIGHT implies filtered for specific format (AMP or AMP4ADS, and only amp.validator.validateSaxEvents, and no detailed errors.

* Generate ValidatorRules.directAttrLists and globalAttrs and ampLayoutAttrs, reducing overhead by indirection.

* Implement parallax effect extension (ampproject#7794)

* Do not set hidden attribute on hide/collapse (ampproject#7879)

* amp-bind: Support `Math` functions (ampproject#7797)

* initial commit for Math in amp-bind

* fix lint

* ali's comment

* avoid scope conflicts with built-in functions

* remove Math functions from documentation

* Measure 3P ad latency (ampproject#7902)

* Update spec URLs from github to ampproject. (ampproject#7901)

* Update github urls to ampproject urls

* test .out updated

* Too many slashes.

* Moved Developing.md and Design_Principles.md (ampproject#7908)

* Rename DEVELOPING.md to contributing/DEVELOPING.md

* Move files to new folder

* Renaming toggle to toggleVisibility because it was conflicting with sidebar and breaking it (ampproject#7855)

* disable scrollRestoration auto for embed case (ampproject#7899)

* Disable Fast Fetch for all ads when remote.html is used. (ampproject#7906)

* Fix DoubleClick Fast Fetch bugs around categoryExclusions and tagForChildDirectedTreatment (ampproject#7843)

* Fix incorrect parameter name for `tagForChildDirectedTreatment` in DoubleClick.

* Added unit test for tagForChildDirectedTreatment.

* Fixed the categoryExclusions bug in Fast Fetch DoubleClick.

* Removed parens in arrow functions to satisfy linter

* Adds two new experiment IDs (ampproject#7850)

* Adds two new experiment IDs to distinguish "any externally triggered" experiment from "any internally triggered".

Also updates tests to remove a number of assumptions that only a single eid will be populated.

* Use return val to detect "externally selected"; test updates.

* Updated network implementation guide. (ampproject#7862)

* Updated network impl guide.

* Changed 'validation' to 'verification'

* Cid timeout error should not be dev error (ampproject#7911)

* Fix amp-ad test (ampproject#7918)

* Update amp-install-serviceworker.md (ampproject#7932)

Fully escape javascript regex.

* Update amp-cache-modifications.md (ampproject#7933)

Add `data-no-service-worker-fallback-shell-url` as a URL to be rewritten as absolute.

* amp-fx-parallax Don't use global (ampproject#7942)

* Viewer integration: rewrite error message to indicate request name (ampproject#7923)

* rewrite error message

* update

* ticks

* Fix up links in DEVELOPING.md (ampproject#7944)

We moved DEVELOPING.md to the contributing folder but didn't update many of the relative links accordingly.

* Popin ad extension document updated. (ampproject#7674)

* Add popin ad extension.

* register popin.

* Add resizeable attribute.

* Remove resizable.

* Implemented the render-start and no-content APIs.

* Fixed lint.

* Remove quatation.

* Use tei@popin.cc

* Rebase old commit .

* Fixed document because tag was not closed.

* I replaced the removed double quotes.

* Add double quotes.

* Support for bind expressions in mustache templates (ampproject#7602)

* first pass at adding/removing subtrees

* tests passing

* Add ability to add and remove bindings in the subtree rooted at a specific node

* lint fixes

* merge conflict

* ci issues

* some cleanup

* pr comments

* pr comments, new method of removing bindings for node and its children

* fix some lint warnings

* test and lint fixes

* mutation observer

* update comments

* add observer

* naive implementation

* cleanup

* clean

* cleanup bind impl

* very simple example of bind in a template

* pr comments

* lint errors

* pr comments

* cleanup

* lint errors

* pr comments

* pr comments and lint warnings

* typo

* comments

* more lint warnings

* pr comment

* change README

* cleanup

* pr comments

* pr comments 2

* lint warnings

* don't use foreach on Nodelist

* casting

* more ci warnings

* even more ci warnings

* even more ci warnings

* even more ci issues

* even more ci comments

* even more ci issues

* pr comments

* more pr comments

* fix refactoring oversight

* pr comments

* pr comments

* merge

* pr comments

* ci issues

* pr comments

* assertElement

* pr comments

* typo

* updating sanitizer

* fixing up sanitizer test

* pr comments

* pr comments

* expanded on amp-mustache tests

* pr comments

* remove class from whitelist

* restore whole sandbox

* update mustache validator test and output

* pr comments

* nexxtv player gulp check-types fixes (ampproject#7816)

* nexxtv player fix error gulp presumbit with postmessage (ampproject#7816)

* added dependency check for nexxtv player (ampproject#7816)

* nexxtv player minor fix in validator (ampproject#7816)

* nexxtv player fixed validator (ampproject#7816)

* fixed validator (ampproject#7816)
mrjoro pushed a commit to mrjoro/amphtml that referenced this pull request Apr 28, 2017
mrjoro pushed a commit to mrjoro/amphtml that referenced this pull request Apr 28, 2017
* initial setup for extension nexxtv-player

* added nexxtv player logic

* nexxtv player bugfixes, cleanup, tests, docs

* added video interface, changed attribute start to seek-to

* reworked video interface for nexxtv-player

* added message handler for nexxtv player and tests

* nexxtv player minor fixes & cleanup

* nexxtv player changed indents from 4 spaces to 2

* added unlayoutCallback for nexxtv player

* initial setup for extension nexxtv-player

* added nexxtv player logic

* nexxtv player bugfixes, cleanup, tests, docs

* added video interface, changed attribute start to seek-to

* reworked video interface for nexxtv-player

* added message handler for nexxtv player and tests

* nexxtv player minor fixes & cleanup

* nexxtv player changed indents from 4 spaces to 2

* added unlayoutCallback for nexxtv player

* fixed linting issues (ampproject#7673)

* initial setup for extension nexxtv-player

* added nexxtv player logic

* nexxtv player bugfixes, cleanup, tests, docs

* added video interface, changed attribute start to seek-to

* reworked video interface for nexxtv-player

* added message handler for nexxtv player and tests

* nexxtv player minor fixes & cleanup

* nexxtv player changed indents from 4 spaces to 2

* added unlayoutCallback for nexxtv player

* initial setup for extension nexxtv-player

* added nexxtv player logic

* nexxtv player bugfixes, cleanup, tests, docs

* added video interface, changed attribute start to seek-to

* reworked video interface for nexxtv-player

* added message handler for nexxtv player and tests

* nexxtv player minor fixes & cleanup

* fixed linting issues (ampproject#7673)

* nexxtv player review fixes (ampproject#7816)

* nexxtv player: updated validation rules (ampproject#7816)

* nexxtv player validator ordered alphabetical, changed spec_url

* fire amp-dom-update event on insert and replace (ampproject#7819)

* temp

* trigger `amp-dom-update` event on insert and replace

* switch -amp-form to i-amp-form

* Validator Rollup (ampproject#7844)

* Revision bump.

* Revision bump for amp-playbuzz changes in ampproject#7450

* Revision bump.

* Allow filtering by HtmlFormat (AMP, AMP4ADS) in the code generator.

* Revision bump.

* Revision bump due to Github pull.

* Code generation now driven by a variable LIGHT, which is broader than the previous GENERATE_DETAILED_ERRORS distinction. LIGHT implies filtered for specific format (AMP or AMP4ADS, and only amp.validator.validateSaxEvents, and no detailed errors.

* Generate ValidatorRules.directAttrLists and globalAttrs and ampLayoutAttrs, reducing overhead by indirection.

* Implement parallax effect extension (ampproject#7794)

* Do not set hidden attribute on hide/collapse (ampproject#7879)

* amp-bind: Support `Math` functions (ampproject#7797)

* initial commit for Math in amp-bind

* fix lint

* ali's comment

* avoid scope conflicts with built-in functions

* remove Math functions from documentation

* Measure 3P ad latency (ampproject#7902)

* Update spec URLs from github to ampproject. (ampproject#7901)

* Update github urls to ampproject urls

* test .out updated

* Too many slashes.

* Moved Developing.md and Design_Principles.md (ampproject#7908)

* Rename DEVELOPING.md to contributing/DEVELOPING.md

* Move files to new folder

* Renaming toggle to toggleVisibility because it was conflicting with sidebar and breaking it (ampproject#7855)

* disable scrollRestoration auto for embed case (ampproject#7899)

* Disable Fast Fetch for all ads when remote.html is used. (ampproject#7906)

* Fix DoubleClick Fast Fetch bugs around categoryExclusions and tagForChildDirectedTreatment (ampproject#7843)

* Fix incorrect parameter name for `tagForChildDirectedTreatment` in DoubleClick.

* Added unit test for tagForChildDirectedTreatment.

* Fixed the categoryExclusions bug in Fast Fetch DoubleClick.

* Removed parens in arrow functions to satisfy linter

* Adds two new experiment IDs (ampproject#7850)

* Adds two new experiment IDs to distinguish "any externally triggered" experiment from "any internally triggered".

Also updates tests to remove a number of assumptions that only a single eid will be populated.

* Use return val to detect "externally selected"; test updates.

* Updated network implementation guide. (ampproject#7862)

* Updated network impl guide.

* Changed 'validation' to 'verification'

* Cid timeout error should not be dev error (ampproject#7911)

* Fix amp-ad test (ampproject#7918)

* Update amp-install-serviceworker.md (ampproject#7932)

Fully escape javascript regex.

* Update amp-cache-modifications.md (ampproject#7933)

Add `data-no-service-worker-fallback-shell-url` as a URL to be rewritten as absolute.

* amp-fx-parallax Don't use global (ampproject#7942)

* Viewer integration: rewrite error message to indicate request name (ampproject#7923)

* rewrite error message

* update

* ticks

* Fix up links in DEVELOPING.md (ampproject#7944)

We moved DEVELOPING.md to the contributing folder but didn't update many of the relative links accordingly.

* Popin ad extension document updated. (ampproject#7674)

* Add popin ad extension.

* register popin.

* Add resizeable attribute.

* Remove resizable.

* Implemented the render-start and no-content APIs.

* Fixed lint.

* Remove quatation.

* Use tei@popin.cc

* Rebase old commit .

* Fixed document because tag was not closed.

* I replaced the removed double quotes.

* Add double quotes.

* Support for bind expressions in mustache templates (ampproject#7602)

* first pass at adding/removing subtrees

* tests passing

* Add ability to add and remove bindings in the subtree rooted at a specific node

* lint fixes

* merge conflict

* ci issues

* some cleanup

* pr comments

* pr comments, new method of removing bindings for node and its children

* fix some lint warnings

* test and lint fixes

* mutation observer

* update comments

* add observer

* naive implementation

* cleanup

* clean

* cleanup bind impl

* very simple example of bind in a template

* pr comments

* lint errors

* pr comments

* cleanup

* lint errors

* pr comments

* pr comments and lint warnings

* typo

* comments

* more lint warnings

* pr comment

* change README

* cleanup

* pr comments

* pr comments 2

* lint warnings

* don't use foreach on Nodelist

* casting

* more ci warnings

* even more ci warnings

* even more ci warnings

* even more ci issues

* even more ci comments

* even more ci issues

* pr comments

* more pr comments

* fix refactoring oversight

* pr comments

* pr comments

* merge

* pr comments

* ci issues

* pr comments

* assertElement

* pr comments

* typo

* updating sanitizer

* fixing up sanitizer test

* pr comments

* pr comments

* expanded on amp-mustache tests

* pr comments

* remove class from whitelist

* restore whole sandbox

* update mustache validator test and output

* pr comments

* nexxtv player gulp check-types fixes (ampproject#7816)

* nexxtv player fix error gulp presumbit with postmessage (ampproject#7816)

* added dependency check for nexxtv player (ampproject#7816)

* nexxtv player minor fix in validator (ampproject#7816)

* nexxtv player fixed validator (ampproject#7816)

* fixed validator (ampproject#7816)
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

3 participants