Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

[readme][grammar]: use singular they pronouns #164

Open
wants to merge 1 commit into
base: master
Choose a base branch
from

Conversation

ckiee
Copy link

@ckiee ckiee commented Oct 12, 2021

This is more inclusive of non-binary people.

See more: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Singular_they

@mwaitzman
This comment has been minimized.
@LoneSimba
Copy link

Please, just stop.

@ckiee
Copy link
Author

ckiee commented Oct 14, 2021

@LoneSimba @mwaitzman
This change is a quality-of-life improvement for gender nonconforming people to make us feel a bit more at home, for me, there's not much more to it; I don't go around looking for stuff like this to make PRs for, I just come upon it [0].

Do you want to make a few people's lives just a bit better for little-to-no effort? I do, and that's all I'm trying to do with this: I don't want to "turn you gay" [1] nor am I trying to erase white cishet [2] men; I just want to get on with my life knowing I've helped others.

[0] In this case, I discovered this on the orange site and I'm pretty sure this is my first PR of this nature.
[1] That is probably impossible.
[2] Cisgender and heterosexual, a.k.a. most of the programmer population.
Sidenote: It'd be nice if you were more clear: telling me to "just stop" without explaining why isn't a very good opening to an argument. Explain why you don't like it.

@vfxdev
Copy link

vfxdev commented Oct 14, 2021

It's a minimal change that does not alter the meaning of the text nor does it reduce its comprehensibility but at the same time helps a few people. I'm confident the inappropriate comments will be ignored and this will be merged swiftly.

@mwaitzman
Copy link

If it was originally like that I'd be fine with it and encourage it for the increased efficiency (significantly less letters), but changing it now is just stupid pandering
We already have an ungodly amount of political correctness infecting the U.S. as it is. Please don't force it onto our repos now too...
In your kind's terms, let this be our "safe space". Don't make us have to deal with your stupid bullshit here, please.

@ckiee
Copy link
Author

ckiee commented Oct 14, 2021

@mwaitzman

In your kind's terms, let this be our "safe space". Don't make us have to deal with your stupid bullshit here, please.

I read: "Don't make us have to consider the fact people that aren't identical to us exist. Let us remain in blissful ignorance."

Where do you get your information / news? Can you verify it elsewhere? (A habit of mine is to DuckDuckGo the same piece of information, but staying unbiased so results from both sides can appear. Not Google since they probably "customize" your search results)

We already have an ungodly amount of political correctness infecting the U.S. as it is

You read PC, I read respecting others.

but changing it now is just stupid pandering

"Stupid pandering" that helps make some people feel at home.
This has already been mentioned to you thrice, try to think of this like you run a program in your head or write a proof in math. It can be helpful to actually understand the other side's thought process, even if you disagree.

@AverseABFun
Copy link

Okay, WOW. I was not expecting to see a bunch of homophobic/transphobic bs today and I really hope this gets merged(I actually noticed this independently when reading the book).

@AverseABFun
Copy link

@mwaitzman @LoneSimba Think about what you have said, but mentally replace "LGBTQ" "enby" "gay" or anything of the sort to "black" or mentally add context that this is racist instead of homophobic or transphobic. We all can agree that racism is bad, right? So is homophobia and transphobia.

@LoneSimba
Copy link

LoneSimba commented Dec 27, 2024

@mwaitzman @LoneSimba Think about what you have said, but mentally replace "LGBTQ" "enby" "gay" or anything of the sort to "black" or mentally add context that this is racist instead of homophobic or transphobic. We all can agree that racism is bad, right? So is homophobia and transphobia.

TBH, don't care about racism, i mean, most of the world seem to hate russians anyways, so why should i care?

Upd: tho, being enter nation or race here != beign mentally ill, imo. (Yes, I'm stating that all those non-binary, trans and other all-colors-of-rainbow people should be visiting therapists, and those, who wont benefit in any way from selling them drugs/medications or rainbow-colored clothes)

@OtterCodes101
Copy link

as a trans person, i do indeed visit a therapist and visit trained professionals, as any sane person would know, you can't just rely on meds to stay sane, you need someone to talk to as well

@AverseABFun
Copy link

@LoneSimba ...

I am agender, asexual, panromantic and the gayest person you can find. tbh, I'm having trouble reading what you just said as I don't even understand what you are trying to say. Except that what I can understand, you are saying that you don't care about racism, homophobia, and transphobia. ALL OF THOSE THINGS, BY DEFINITION, EMOTIONALLY HURT PEOPLE. Also, LGBTQ != needs therapy. LGBTQ means we identify a certain way, not that we act in such a way that we need mental help.

@kosmas12
Copy link

kosmas12 commented Dec 27, 2024

Gender-related discussion or not, using "they" just makes more sense. It's much more efficient than saying "his or her" as some have pointed out here and it just feels more gramatically correct. I don't get why this PR hasn't already been merged and people are instead arguing

@LoneSimba
Copy link

@LoneSimba ...

I am agender, asexual, panromantic and the gayest person you can find. tbh, I'm having trouble reading what you just said as I don't even understand what you are trying to say. Except that what I can understand, you are saying that you don't care about racism, homophobia, and transphobia. ALL OF THOSE THINGS, BY DEFINITION, EMOTIONALLY HURT PEOPLE. Also, LGBTQ != needs therapy. LGBTQ means we identify a certain way, not that we act in such a way that we need mental help.

You may think so. What I'm saying, is that people are biologically either a male or a female. Either XX or XY. If your mental state doesn't match - then it's a health issue. Most likely, caused by some traumatic experiences. And i see supporting this instead of treating as a crime.

@LoneSimba
Copy link

Gender-related discussion or not, using "they" just makes more sense. It's much more efficient than saying "his or her" as some have pointed out here and it just feels more gramatically correct. I don't get why this PR hasn't already been merged and people are instead arguing

That is true

@AverseABFun
Copy link

@LoneSimba You may think so. What I'm saying, is that people are biologically either a male or a female. Either XX or XY. If your mental state doesn't match - then it's a health issue. Most likely, caused by some traumatic experiences. And i see supporting this instead of treating as a crime.

  1. Ever heard of intersex? 2. Transgender people are people too, and when trans people take hormones outside of genetic markers they become biologically whatever sex they choose to become. 3. MENTAL STATE HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH SEX! YOU DON'T GO TO "The Female Therapist" or "The Male Therapist" WHEN YOU GET THERAPY! 4. There are so, so, SO many other ways for mental state to change outside of traumatic experiences. If you don't think so, cite your sources.

@LoneSimba
Copy link

@LoneSimba You may think so. What I'm saying, is that people are biologically either a male or a female. Either XX or XY. If your mental state doesn't match - then it's a health issue. Most likely, caused by some traumatic experiences. And i see supporting this instead of treating as a crime.

  1. Ever heard of intersex? 2. Transgender people are people too, and when trans people take hormones outside of genetic markers they become biologically whatever sex they choose to become. 3. MENTAL STATE HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH SEX! YOU DON'T GO TO "The Female Therapist" or "The Male Therapist" WHEN YOU GET THERAPY! 4. There are so, so, SO many other ways for mental state to change outside of traumatic experiences. If you don't think so, cite your sources.
  1. There is no biologically intersex people. You are always are born with either a penile or a vag, XY or XX 2. They take hormones. Its not what their body produces, and i saw a lot of ppl who switched back and forth and then said it was a mistake and now their body is really screwed up because of those medications. 3. Yes it does. And yes, i do go the "the male therapist". 4. Yes, there are. But it won't change your genome. XY imprinted in the mothers womb will stay XY no matter how much pills you take or how much surgery you do

@OtterCodes101
Copy link

i've tried to stay as fucking neutral as i could with this but you're just coping at this point
Biologically intersex people exist
It is indeed possible to have chromosomes other than XX or XY
Go look into a lil' thing called advanced biology

@ALEXLINCHEVSKY
Copy link

Transphobia or homophobia means fear, since phobos means Fear in Greek. According to this, pornophobes and homophobes should logically be afraid of LGBTQ+ people. Some unhealthy people classify me as transphobic and homophobic, simply because I hold different views. and having dealt with terminology and origin, I found my identity. Because of mentally ill LGBTQ+ people, I have developed another mental disorder and it is called misogomy, like misanthropy. that is, hatred and distrust of LGBTQ+. That is, I am not afraid of them, but simply hate them.

LGBTQ+ issues have nothing to do with the development of Operating Systems and all the issues mentioned in this book.
and all of this is LGBTQ+, the same social construct created just 10-15 years ago. Аnd it is not an integral part of Information Technology, programming and development.

@OtterCodes101
Copy link

Transphobia or homophobia means fear, since phobos means Fear in Greek. According to this, pornophobes and homophobes should logically be afraid of LGBTQ+ people. Some unhealthy people classify me as transphobic and homophobic, simply because I hold different views. and having dealt with terminology and origin, I found my identity. Because of mentally ill LGBTQ+ people, I have developed another mental disorder and it is called misogomy, like misanthropy. that is, hatred and distrust of LGBTQ+. That is, I am not afraid of them, but simply hate them.

LGBTQ+ issues have nothing to do with the development of Operating Systems and all the issues mentioned in this book. and all of this is LGBTQ+, the same social construct created just 10-15 years ago. Аnd it is not an integral part of Information Technology, programming and development.

(no, i'm not saying you're right or you're wrong, this is just a small comment)
words like transphobia and homophobia in this case usually mean hate instead of the usual meaning of fear. take, for example, arachnophobia means you're afraid of spiders. Transphobia and homophobia usually are instead used with a definition that someone is opposed to LGBTQ+ people, rather than being afraid of them.
also, I really doubt debating this PR will really make a difference at this point. The author appears to have abandoned this, so there's not even a good chance this PR will ever get merged.

@AverseABFun
Copy link

Transphobia or homophobia means fear, since phobos means Fear in Greek. According to this, pornophobes and homophobes should logically be afraid of LGBTQ+ people. Some unhealthy people classify me as transphobic and homophobic, simply because I hold different views. and having dealt with terminology and origin, I found my identity. Because of mentally ill LGBTQ+ people, I have developed another mental disorder and it is called misogomy, like misanthropy. that is, hatred and distrust of LGBTQ+. That is, I am not afraid of them, but simply hate them.

LGBTQ+ issues have nothing to do with the development of Operating Systems and all the issues mentioned in this book. and all of this is LGBTQ+, the same social construct created just 10-15 years ago. Аnd it is not an integral part of Information Technology, programming and development.

this is not about LGBTQ+ issues(aka, our entire existence for some reason), it's about us not being erased. LGBTQ+ also was not created 10-15 years ago; the ancient Maya civilization and many others recognized a third gender(see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Third_gender#Mesoamerica) and other queer identities have been respected in other ancient civilizations(https://www.worldhistory.org/article/1790/lgbtq-in-the-ancient-world/).

it is not an integral part of Information Technology, programming and development.

But that's the thing; it is. Not a majority of people are queer-identifying in tech, however a large number of people are and this change both doesn't affect you and if anything will be beneficial.

Because of mentally ill LGBTQ+ people, I have developed another mental disorder and it is called misogomy[sic], like misanthropy. that is, hatred and distrust of LGBTQ+. That is, I am not afraid of them, but simply hate them.

Okay. I didn't really want to get into this but saying that because of mentally ill people you have literally started hating their group is a massive problem and this is equivalent to saying directly to multiple black people's faces, "Because of mentally ill black people, I've developed a mental disorder called raiscm, like misanthropy. that is, hatred and distrust of black people." As you can see, that definitely wouldn't be okay, and so this is not okay either. Also, enjoy being blocked and reported.

@AverseABFun
Copy link

Even despite all of this, even if somehow(hint: it's not) you are right, using they is still more efficient and shorter. This didn't need to turn into a dumpster fire; you queerphobic people turned it into one.

@tuhdo can this please be merged? no matter your stance on queer people(which I would like to know in case I should avoid this at all costs because I don't want to support queerphobic people), as I just said this is shorter and not a big change.

@Ubsefor
Copy link

Ubsefor commented Feb 22, 2025

I’ll just leave it here: https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/czx84en1yp4o

I suggest finding something else to damage with LGBTQabcdefg+ stuff.

@OtterCodes101
Copy link

OtterCodes101 commented Feb 22, 2025

I’ll just leave it here: https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/czx84en1yp4o

I suggest finding something else to damage with LGBTQabcdefg+ stuff.

fun fact: in this specific executive order, trump fucked up with the definition of "female" and now everyone is legally female according to him

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

9 participants