Checklist: Stage 4 entrance criteria

[leobalter]

• Test262 Status: https://test262.report/features/numeric-separator-literal
• At least 2 implementations shipping the feature without flags:
  • V8
  • SpiderMonkey
  • JavaScriptCore
  • ChakraCore
  • Hermes
  • Moddable XS
  • QuickJS
• Babel
• PR to ECMA-262
  • Editors sign-off (WIP)

[chicoxyzzy]

It's implemented in V8 now

[samuelgoto]

It should be coming out on M75: https://www.chromestatus.com/features/5829906369871872

…

On Tue, Apr 16, 2019 at 2:01 PM Sergey Rubanov ***@***.***> wrote: It's implemented in V8 now — You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub <#43 (comment)>, or mute the thread <https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AAqV6ncGN5HCHij9f8rYos3psG80Clfeks5vhjo7gaJpZM4cQXkG> .

-- f u cn rd ths u cn b a gd prgmr !

[leobalter]

needs shipping (M75) to flag the box :)

[chicoxyzzy]

Implemented in Firefox Nightly 68 which will be released on July 9

Chrome 75 will be released on June 4

[boingoing]

This is implemented in ChakraCore now (chakra-core/ChakraCore#6143).

I'm not sure what the schedule is for cutting a new release branch with this enabled, though.

[chicoxyzzy]

Implemented in Safari TP 85 https://webkit.org/blog/9281/release-notes-for-safari-technology-preview-85/

[chicoxyzzy]

Shipped in Safari 13 update which is bundled with macOS Catalina beta

[ljharb]

Note that additional stage 4 entrance criteria include having an editor-approved PR to the main spec.

[chicoxyzzy]

@leobalter I think you can add check marks for JSC, ChakraCore and TypeScript. Firefox will have numerics separators support enabled by default in version 70, which is planned for October 22.

[leobalter]

It's on for ChakraCore but still w/ a flag, if I'm correct.

Thanks for the update. Now it's time for the champions to move this forward. cc @rwaldron @samuelgoto

[chicoxyzzy]

It looks like default value for numeric separator flag in ChakraCore is true. Though I could miss something.

[rhuanjl]

@chicoxyzzy if you build chakracore for yourself from the master branch this feature is enabled. However if you download a released version of chakracore or use Edge this feature is not there. The last release of chakracore to incorporate any new feature work was in June 2018 (version 1.10) all releases since then have been security fixes only. A lot of feature work has been done since then but it's all only in the master branch and hence only usable by people who compile it themselves.

[chicoxyzzy]

@rhuanjl thank you for the clarification

[avp]

Added to Hermes in facebook/hermes@f0006aa

[leobalter]

Thanks @avp! I updated the list to reflect this.

[tchetwin]

https://github.com/tc39/proposals/blob/master/finished-proposals.md ES2021 :)