-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 3.5k
New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
Chapter 3.2: Integer division rounding is described incorrectly #2856
Closed
2 tasks done
Milestone
Comments
This isn't right yet. Currently, the code listing for the ch03-02 Numeric Operations section says:
Instead, it should say:
Consider how integer division and flooring work. Integer division results in truncation—and not in flooring. For example, this code: fn main() {
let below_negative_two: f32 = -9.0 / 4.0; // This equals -2.25
let floored = below_negative_two.floor();
println!("Floored: {:?}", floored);
let truncated = -9 / 4;
println!("Truncated: {:?}", truncated);
} produces this result:
|
carols10cents
added a commit
that referenced
this issue
Sep 16, 2022
carols10cents
added a commit
that referenced
this issue
Sep 18, 2022
compiler-errors
added a commit
to compiler-errors/rust
that referenced
this issue
Oct 25, 2022
Update books ## reference 4 commits in f6ed74f582bddcec73f753eafaab3749c4f7df61..4ea7c5def38ac81df33a9e48e5637a82a5ac404d 2022-10-08 02:43:26 -0700 to 2022-10-25 15:14:36 -0700 - Document Half Open Range Patterns + Improve Range Patterns in General (rust-lang/reference#1274) - clarifying which row contains the example (rust-lang/reference#1287) - Add `sym` operands for inline assembly (rust-lang/reference#1270) - Add basic GATs reference information (rust-lang/reference#1265) ## book 141 commits in f1e5ad844d0c61738006cdef26227beeb136948e..aa5ee485bd6bd80d205da7c82fcdd776f92fdd51 2022-09-19 09:48:21 -0400 to 2022-10-20 16:49:55 -0400 - Remove Turkish translation - Update chapter 4 from latest print edits - Update chapter 3 from latest print edits - Clarify division truncates toward zero. Fixes rust-lang/book#2856. - Update chapter 2 from latest print edits - Fix a problem with literal style ending - Explain both kinds of format string arguments - Update chapter 1 from latest print edits - Snapshot consolidated appendices - Fix ListNumber0, newlines after lists - Don't match nodes without anything - Handle listing numbers in appendices too - Regenerate everything - Fix chapter numbers in word doc so they're in the XML - Number Table captions too - Handle figures too - Regenerate ch4 - Handle listing numbers - Regenerate ch13 - Regenerate ch12 - Regenerate ch11 - Regenerate chapter 10 - Fix ListBullet0 - Handle ending of BoxCode better - Regenerate chapter 9 - Regenerate ch8 - Make RunInHead consistent-ish - Fix extra newline before boxes - Fix Box RunIn Head/Para - Fix newline after RunInHead/Para - Regenerate ch7 - Fix QuotePara - Fix ListPlain - Regenerate ch6 - Fix BoxCode - Regenerate chapter 5 - Fix GraphicSlug and CaptionLine - Regenerate snapshot of chapter 4 - Fix boxes a bit - Add a shellcheck ignore - Handle BoxListBullet - Handle superscript - Regenerate ch3 from xml and fix tables - Fix italics and whitespace interactions - Fix italic preceding/following - Fix preceding/following xpaths again - Fix italics - Fix code blocks - Fix more last bullets in lists - Fix box newlines - Fix last bullet in a list - Fix BoxType - Fix notes - Fix literals - Add the no editing warning at the top when getting snapshots from docx - Make the snapshot of the frontmatter nicer - Updates to appendixes C, D, and E after copyedit checks - Snapshots after copyedit checks of appendices a and b + recheck of 20 - Snapshot of appendices from copyedit - Updated snapshot of the appendices - Re-checks of chapter 19 - Re-checks of chapter 18 - Messy snapshot of chapter 20 after copyedit checks - Snapshot of ch20 after copyedit - Updated snapshot of chapter 20 - Messy snapshot of chapter 19 after copyedit checks - Snapshot of ch19 after copyedit - Updated snapshot of ch19 - Messy snapshot of ch 18 after copyedit review - Snapshot of ch 18 after copyedit - Update snapshot of ch18 - Messy snapshot of ch 17 after copyedit review - Snapshot of ch17 copyedit - Updated snapshot of ch17 - Messy snapshot of ch16 after copyedit - Snapshot of ch16 copyedited - Updated snapshot of ch16 - Messy snapshot of ch 15 after copyedit checks - Re-review of earlier chapters - Snapshot of ch15 copyedit - Update snapshot of ch15 - Messy snapshots of other chapters with indentation fixed - Messy snapshot of ch2 with indentation fixed - Add unittests to the allowed words - Messy snapshot of chapter 14 after checking copyedit - Snapshot of chapter 14 after copyedit - Update snapshot of ch14 - Regenerate manual output for chapter 14 - Messy snapshot of chapter 13 after copyedit check - Updated snapshot of ch13 after copyedit - Updated snapshot of ch13 - Messy snapshot of chapter 12 after copyedit checks - Snapshot of chapter 12 copyedited - Update snapshot for chapter 12 - Messy snapshot of chapter 11 after copyedit check - Snapshot of chapter 11 copyedited - Updated snapshot of chapter 11 - Messy snapshot of chapter 10 after copyedit check - Snapshot of chapter 10 copyedit - Updated snapshot of chapter 10 - Messy snapshot of ch9 after copyedit checks - Snapshot of ch 9 copyedit - Update snapshot of chapter 9 - Messy snapshot of chapter 8 - Update println style in ch8 - Snapshot of chapter 8 from copyedit - Updated snapshot of chapter 8 - Rearrange my notes yet again - Messy snapshot of ch7 after copyedit checks - Snapshot of chapter 7 from copyedit, fix chapter 6 name - Update snapshot of chapter 7 - Messy snapshot of chapter 6 after copyedit check - Update snapshot of chapter 6 - Change my notes again - Messy snapshot of chapter 5 after checking copyedit - Snapshot of chapter 5 from copyedit - Messy snapshot of chapter 4 after copyedit check - Changing my notes again - Snapshot of ch4 from nostarch - Messy snapshot of chapter 3 after copyedit check, ch4 on start check - Snapshot of ch3 from nostarch - Updated snapshot of ch3 - reorder notes - Messy snapshot of chapter 1 after copyedit check - Snapshot of ch01 docx from nostarch - Updated snapshot of chapter 1 - Messy snapshot of frontmatter docx - Another snapshot to fix the crab pinchers description - Messy snapshot of chapter 2 docx - Get the latest snapshot of chapter 2 - Upgrade to rand 0.8.5 - Notes to self - Update xsl and take snapshots from docx, such as they are - Update instructions on docx -> md now that I've done it again - Propagate frontmatter edits to src - Updated snapshots extracted from frontmatter - Support different styles in the docx - Line wrap bio - Frontmatter from word doc - Edits to docx files for nostarch - docx files from nostarch ## rust-by-example 6 commits in 5e7b296d6c345addbd748f242aae28c42555c015..03491f33375c5a2a1661c7fa4be671fe95ce1249 2022-10-05 08:24:45 -0300 to 2022-10-21 07:30:08 -0300 - fix rust-lang/rust-by-example#1628: the box pointer is on stack not on heap (rust-lang/rust-by-example#1629) - fix rust-lang/rust-by-example#1608: out-of-bound indexing is a runtime error (not a compile-time error) (rust-lang/rust-by-example#1626 ) - Fix: Path internal representation and conversions (rust-lang/rust-by-example#1625) - fix crate name in example (rust-lang/rust-by-example#1620) - avoid reserved keyword try as crate name (rust-lang/rust-by-example#1619) - Fix typo in iter_result.md (rust-lang/rust-by-example#1614) ## rustc-dev-guide 7 commits in 7518c34..51a37ad 2022-10-08 12:29:47 +0200 to 2022-10-25 10:18:58 -0700 - Update `traits/resolution.md` (rust-lang/rustc-dev-guide#1494) - Update diagnostics to flat fluent message paths - Update rust-analyzer suggestions (rust-lang/rustc-dev-guide#1487) - miri is no longer a submodule but a subtree. (rust-lang/rustc-dev-guide#1488) - fix some links (rust-lang/rustc-dev-guide#1490) - typo and grammar (rust-lang/rustc-dev-guide#1484) - Add missing prerequisite for some Linux distros (rust-lang/rustc-dev-guide#1481)
Dylan-DPC
added a commit
to Dylan-DPC/rust
that referenced
this issue
Oct 26, 2022
Update books ## reference 4 commits in f6ed74f582bddcec73f753eafaab3749c4f7df61..4ea7c5def38ac81df33a9e48e5637a82a5ac404d 2022-10-08 02:43:26 -0700 to 2022-10-25 15:14:36 -0700 - Document Half Open Range Patterns + Improve Range Patterns in General (rust-lang/reference#1274) - clarifying which row contains the example (rust-lang/reference#1287) - Add `sym` operands for inline assembly (rust-lang/reference#1270) - Add basic GATs reference information (rust-lang/reference#1265) ## book 141 commits in f1e5ad844d0c61738006cdef26227beeb136948e..aa5ee485bd6bd80d205da7c82fcdd776f92fdd51 2022-09-19 09:48:21 -0400 to 2022-10-20 16:49:55 -0400 - Remove Turkish translation - Update chapter 4 from latest print edits - Update chapter 3 from latest print edits - Clarify division truncates toward zero. Fixes rust-lang/book#2856. - Update chapter 2 from latest print edits - Fix a problem with literal style ending - Explain both kinds of format string arguments - Update chapter 1 from latest print edits - Snapshot consolidated appendices - Fix ListNumber0, newlines after lists - Don't match nodes without anything - Handle listing numbers in appendices too - Regenerate everything - Fix chapter numbers in word doc so they're in the XML - Number Table captions too - Handle figures too - Regenerate ch4 - Handle listing numbers - Regenerate ch13 - Regenerate ch12 - Regenerate ch11 - Regenerate chapter 10 - Fix ListBullet0 - Handle ending of BoxCode better - Regenerate chapter 9 - Regenerate ch8 - Make RunInHead consistent-ish - Fix extra newline before boxes - Fix Box RunIn Head/Para - Fix newline after RunInHead/Para - Regenerate ch7 - Fix QuotePara - Fix ListPlain - Regenerate ch6 - Fix BoxCode - Regenerate chapter 5 - Fix GraphicSlug and CaptionLine - Regenerate snapshot of chapter 4 - Fix boxes a bit - Add a shellcheck ignore - Handle BoxListBullet - Handle superscript - Regenerate ch3 from xml and fix tables - Fix italics and whitespace interactions - Fix italic preceding/following - Fix preceding/following xpaths again - Fix italics - Fix code blocks - Fix more last bullets in lists - Fix box newlines - Fix last bullet in a list - Fix BoxType - Fix notes - Fix literals - Add the no editing warning at the top when getting snapshots from docx - Make the snapshot of the frontmatter nicer - Updates to appendixes C, D, and E after copyedit checks - Snapshots after copyedit checks of appendices a and b + recheck of 20 - Snapshot of appendices from copyedit - Updated snapshot of the appendices - Re-checks of chapter 19 - Re-checks of chapter 18 - Messy snapshot of chapter 20 after copyedit checks - Snapshot of ch20 after copyedit - Updated snapshot of chapter 20 - Messy snapshot of chapter 19 after copyedit checks - Snapshot of ch19 after copyedit - Updated snapshot of ch19 - Messy snapshot of ch 18 after copyedit review - Snapshot of ch 18 after copyedit - Update snapshot of ch18 - Messy snapshot of ch 17 after copyedit review - Snapshot of ch17 copyedit - Updated snapshot of ch17 - Messy snapshot of ch16 after copyedit - Snapshot of ch16 copyedited - Updated snapshot of ch16 - Messy snapshot of ch 15 after copyedit checks - Re-review of earlier chapters - Snapshot of ch15 copyedit - Update snapshot of ch15 - Messy snapshots of other chapters with indentation fixed - Messy snapshot of ch2 with indentation fixed - Add unittests to the allowed words - Messy snapshot of chapter 14 after checking copyedit - Snapshot of chapter 14 after copyedit - Update snapshot of ch14 - Regenerate manual output for chapter 14 - Messy snapshot of chapter 13 after copyedit check - Updated snapshot of ch13 after copyedit - Updated snapshot of ch13 - Messy snapshot of chapter 12 after copyedit checks - Snapshot of chapter 12 copyedited - Update snapshot for chapter 12 - Messy snapshot of chapter 11 after copyedit check - Snapshot of chapter 11 copyedited - Updated snapshot of chapter 11 - Messy snapshot of chapter 10 after copyedit check - Snapshot of chapter 10 copyedit - Updated snapshot of chapter 10 - Messy snapshot of ch9 after copyedit checks - Snapshot of ch 9 copyedit - Update snapshot of chapter 9 - Messy snapshot of chapter 8 - Update println style in ch8 - Snapshot of chapter 8 from copyedit - Updated snapshot of chapter 8 - Rearrange my notes yet again - Messy snapshot of ch7 after copyedit checks - Snapshot of chapter 7 from copyedit, fix chapter 6 name - Update snapshot of chapter 7 - Messy snapshot of chapter 6 after copyedit check - Update snapshot of chapter 6 - Change my notes again - Messy snapshot of chapter 5 after checking copyedit - Snapshot of chapter 5 from copyedit - Messy snapshot of chapter 4 after copyedit check - Changing my notes again - Snapshot of ch4 from nostarch - Messy snapshot of chapter 3 after copyedit check, ch4 on start check - Snapshot of ch3 from nostarch - Updated snapshot of ch3 - reorder notes - Messy snapshot of chapter 1 after copyedit check - Snapshot of ch01 docx from nostarch - Updated snapshot of chapter 1 - Messy snapshot of frontmatter docx - Another snapshot to fix the crab pinchers description - Messy snapshot of chapter 2 docx - Get the latest snapshot of chapter 2 - Upgrade to rand 0.8.5 - Notes to self - Update xsl and take snapshots from docx, such as they are - Update instructions on docx -> md now that I've done it again - Propagate frontmatter edits to src - Updated snapshots extracted from frontmatter - Support different styles in the docx - Line wrap bio - Frontmatter from word doc - Edits to docx files for nostarch - docx files from nostarch ## rust-by-example 6 commits in 5e7b296d6c345addbd748f242aae28c42555c015..03491f33375c5a2a1661c7fa4be671fe95ce1249 2022-10-05 08:24:45 -0300 to 2022-10-21 07:30:08 -0300 - fix rust-lang/rust-by-example#1628: the box pointer is on stack not on heap (rust-lang/rust-by-example#1629) - fix rust-lang/rust-by-example#1608: out-of-bound indexing is a runtime error (not a compile-time error) (rust-lang/rust-by-example#1626 ) - Fix: Path internal representation and conversions (rust-lang/rust-by-example#1625) - fix crate name in example (rust-lang/rust-by-example#1620) - avoid reserved keyword try as crate name (rust-lang/rust-by-example#1619) - Fix typo in iter_result.md (rust-lang/rust-by-example#1614) ## rustc-dev-guide 7 commits in 7518c34..51a37ad 2022-10-08 12:29:47 +0200 to 2022-10-25 10:18:58 -0700 - Update `traits/resolution.md` (rust-lang/rustc-dev-guide#1494) - Update diagnostics to flat fluent message paths - Update rust-analyzer suggestions (rust-lang/rustc-dev-guide#1487) - miri is no longer a submodule but a subtree. (rust-lang/rustc-dev-guide#1488) - fix some links (rust-lang/rustc-dev-guide#1490) - typo and grammar (rust-lang/rustc-dev-guide#1484) - Add missing prerequisite for some Linux distros (rust-lang/rustc-dev-guide#1481)
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment
main
branch to see if this has already been fixedURL to the section(s) of the book with this problem:
https://doc.rust-lang.org/book/ch03-02-data-types.html#numeric-operations (but only in a newer version than on the web site)
Description of the problem:
With the fix for #2248, the book states:
and has the example:
However, on godbolt, the behavior I observe is instead truncation toward zero.
outputs
I believe this is true on all architectures supported by Rust: the Rust Reference states "Integer division rounds towards zero."
Suggested fix:
floored
totruncated
orrounded_toward_zero
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: