Suggest adding an entrance=* node to fix 'disconnected highway' errors

[k-yle]

Closes #6341

If an isolated path or road connects to a building outline, the validator has a new autofix suggestion, which adds entrance=yes or amenity=parking_entrance to the node:

[k-yle]

Ideally this would be rephrased to remove the indefinite article, any suggestions would be appreciated.

[tordans]

I tend to use this pattern in similar situations

Suggested change

	title: Mark the endpoint as a {presetName}
	title: Mark the endpoint as »{presetName}«

[tordans]

Thanks for this, I think it is a good addition.

Does https://github.com/openstreetmap/iD/pull/10729/files#diff-aa67428c964bd0d0ac6939c0545ffa404cbc3237b1dffec3b2a22491fbac8988R232-R234 mean that this suggestion will either suggest entrance=yes for path like highways and otherwise amenity=parking_entrance?

I wonder if this is the best second option in most cases.

In Berlin, we commonly use barrier=gate for those hw=service ways that connect to a building

• https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/6320148742
• https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/6896812829

Parking entrance is also present sometimes, though https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/8003765396

[tordans]

I tend to use this pattern in similar situations

Suggested change

	title: Mark the endpoint as a {presetName}
	title: Mark the endpoint as »{presetName}«

[k-yle]

Does https://github.com/openstreetmap/iD/pull/10729/files#diff-aa67428c964bd0d0ac6939c0545ffa404cbc3237b1dffec3b2a22491fbac8988R232-R234 mean that this suggestion will either suggest entrance=yes for path like highways and otherwise amenity=parking_entrance?

Yes. Maybe this autofix should only apply to path-like ways? I suspect that isolated vehiclular ways are quite rare, compared to isolated pathways

[tordans]

Yes. Maybe this autofix should only apply to path-like ways?

Maybe to make this PR easier to merge because I consider this case very clear.

I suspect that isolated vehiclular ways are quite rare, compared to isolated pathways

Actually, we have many such cases in Berlin where a barrier=gate (and maybe barrier=entrance – no gate, just no one added the building passage way, yet) would be welcome additions. See those lines in https://www.openstreetmap.org/#map=19/52.471610/13.444500 for example.

FYI: Those service ways are important data that we add in Berlin to have data that we can use during parking pane processing (https://parkraum.osm-verkehrswende.org/). But those tags at the building are left out often because its already a lot of clicks to add the driveway.