esm: detect ESM syntax in ambiguous JavaScript

PR-URL: #50096
Reviewed-By: Yagiz Nizipli <yagiz@nizipli.com>
Reviewed-By: Benjamin Gruenbaum <benjamingr@gmail.com>
Reviewed-By: Guy Bedford <guybedford@gmail.com>

benchmark/esm/detect-esm-syntax.js

@@ -0,0 +1,37 @@
+'use strict';
+
+// This benchmarks the cost of running `containsModuleSyntax` on a CommonJS module being imported.
+// We use the TypeScript fixture because it's a very large CommonJS file with no ESM syntax: the worst case.
+const common = require('../common.js');
+const tmpdir = require('../../test/common/tmpdir.js');
+const fixtures = require('../../test/common/fixtures.js');
+const scriptPath = fixtures.path('snapshot', 'typescript.js');
+const fs = require('node:fs');
+
+const bench = common.createBenchmark(main, {
+  type: ['with-module-syntax-detection', 'without-module-syntax-detection'],
+  n: [1e4],
+}, {
+  flags: ['--experimental-detect-module'],
+});
+
+const benchmarkDirectory = tmpdir.fileURL('benchmark-detect-esm-syntax');
+const ambiguousURL = new URL('./typescript.js', benchmarkDirectory);
+const explicitURL = new URL('./typescript.cjs', benchmarkDirectory);
+
+async function main({ n, type }) {
+  tmpdir.refresh();
+
+  fs.mkdirSync(benchmarkDirectory, { recursive: true });
+  fs.cpSync(scriptPath, ambiguousURL);
+  fs.cpSync(scriptPath, explicitURL);
+
+  bench.start();
+
+  for (let i = 0; i < n; i++) {
+    const url = type === 'with-module-syntax-detection' ? ambiguousURL : explicitURL;
+    await import(url);
+  }
+
+  bench.end(n);
+}

doc/api/cli.md

@@ -620,6 +620,32 @@ files with no extension will be treated as WebAssembly if they begin with the
 WebAssembly magic number (`\0asm`); otherwise they will be treated as ES module
 JavaScript.
 
+### `--experimental-detect-module`
+
+<!-- YAML
+added:
+  - REPLACEME
+-->
+
+> Stability: 1.0 - Early development
+
+Node.js will inspect the source code of ambiguous input to determine whether it
+contains ES module syntax; if such syntax is detected, the input will be treated
+as an ES module.
+
+Ambiguous input is defined as:
+
+* Files with a `.js` extension or no extension; and either no controlling
+  `package.json` file or one that lacks a `type` field; and
+  `--experimental-default-type` is not specified.
+* String input (`--eval` or STDIN) when neither `--input-type` nor
+  `--experimental-default-type` are specified.
+
+ES module syntax is defined as syntax that would throw when evaluated as
+CommonJS. This includes `import` and `export` statements and `import.meta`
+references. It does _not_ include `import()` expressions, which are valid in
+CommonJS.
+
 ### `--experimental-import-meta-resolve`
 
 <!-- YAML
@@ -2286,6 +2312,7 @@ Node.js options that are allowed are:
 * `--enable-source-maps`
 * `--experimental-abortcontroller`
 * `--experimental-default-type`
+* `--experimental-detect-module`
 * `--experimental-import-meta-resolve`
 * `--experimental-json-modules`
 * `--experimental-loader`

doc/api/esm.md

@@ -109,11 +109,21 @@ provides interoperability between them and its original module format,
 
 Node.js has two module systems: [CommonJS][] modules and ECMAScript modules.
 
-Authors can tell Node.js to use the ECMAScript modules loader via the `.mjs`
-file extension, the `package.json` [`"type"`][] field, the [`--input-type`][]
-flag, or the [`--experimental-default-type`][] flag. Outside of those cases,
-Node.js will use the CommonJS module loader. See [Determining module system][]
-for more details.
+Authors can tell Node.js to interpret JavaScript as an ES module via the `.mjs`
+file extension, the `package.json` [`"type"`][] field with a value `"module"`,
+the [`--input-type`][] flag with a value of `"module"`, or the
+[`--experimental-default-type`][] flag with a value of `"module"`. These are
+explicit markers of code being intended to run as an ES module.
+
+Inversely, authors can tell Node.js to interpret JavaScript as CommonJS via the
+`.cjs` file extension, the `package.json` [`"type"`][] field with a value
+`"commonjs"`, the [`--input-type`][] flag with a value of `"commonjs"`, or the
+[`--experimental-default-type`][] flag with a value of `"commonjs"`.
+
+When code lacks explicit markers for either module system, Node.js will inspect
+the source code of a module to look for ES module syntax. If such syntax is
+found, Node.js will run the code as an ES module; otherwise it will run the
+module as CommonJS. See [Determining module system][] for more details.
 
 <!-- Anchors to make sure old links find a target -->
 
@@ -1019,18 +1029,33 @@ _isImports_, _conditions_)
 >    1. Return _"commonjs"_.
 > 4. If _url_ ends in _".json"_, then
 >    1. Return _"json"_.
-> 5. Let _packageURL_ be the result of **LOOKUP\_PACKAGE\_SCOPE**(_url_).
-> 6. Let _pjson_ be the result of **READ\_PACKAGE\_JSON**(_packageURL_).
-> 7. If _pjson?.type_ exists and is _"module"_, then
->    1. If _url_ ends in _".js"_ or has no file extension, then
->       1. If `--experimental-wasm-modules` is enabled and the file at _url_
->          contains the header for a WebAssembly module, then
->          1. Return _"wasm"_.
->       2. Otherwise,
->          1. Return _"module"_.
->    2. Return **undefined**.
-> 8. Otherwise,
->    1. Return **undefined**.
+> 5. If `--experimental-wasm-modules` is enabled and _url_ ends in
+>    _".wasm"_, then
+>    1. Return _"wasm"_.
+> 6. Let _packageURL_ be the result of **LOOKUP\_PACKAGE\_SCOPE**(_url_).
+> 7. Let _pjson_ be the result of **READ\_PACKAGE\_JSON**(_packageURL_).
+> 8. Let _packageType_ be **null**.
+> 9. If _pjson?.type_ is _"module"_ or _"commonjs"_, then
+>    1. Set _packageType_ to _pjson.type_.
+> 10. If _url_ ends in _".js"_, then
+>     1. If _packageType_ is not **null**, then
+>        1. Return _packageType_.
+>     2. If `--experimental-detect-module` is enabled and the source of
+>        module contains static import or export syntax, then
+>        1. Return _"module"_.
+>     3. Return _"commonjs"_.
+> 11. If _url_ does not have any extension, then
+>     1. If _packageType_ is _"module"_ and `--experimental-wasm-modules` is
+>        enabled and the file at _url_ contains the header for a WebAssembly
+>        module, then
+>        1. Return _"wasm"_.
+>     2. If _packageType_ is not **null**, then
+>        1. Return _packageType_.
+>     3. If `--experimental-detect-module` is enabled and the source of
+>        module contains static import or export syntax, then
+>        1. Return _"module"_.
+>     4. Return _"commonjs"_.
+> 12. Return **undefined** (will throw during load phase).
 
 **LOOKUP\_PACKAGE\_SCOPE**(_url_)
 

doc/api/modules.md

@@ -80,8 +80,10 @@ By default, Node.js will treat the following as CommonJS modules:
 * Files with a `.js` extension when the nearest parent `package.json` file
   contains a top-level field [`"type"`][] with a value of `"commonjs"`.
 
-* Files with a `.js` extension when the nearest parent `package.json` file
-  doesn't contain a top-level field [`"type"`][]. Package authors should include
+* Files with a `.js` extension or without an extension, when the nearest parent
+  `package.json` file doesn't contain a top-level field [`"type"`][] or there is
+  no `package.json` in any parent folder; unless the file contains syntax that
+  errors unless it is evaluated as an ES module. Package authors should include
   the [`"type"`][] field, even in packages where all sources are CommonJS. Being
   explicit about the `type` of the package will make things easier for build
   tools and loaders to determine how the files in the package should be

doc/api/packages.md

@@ -69,6 +69,14 @@ expressions:
 * Strings passed in as an argument to `--eval`, or piped to `node` via `STDIN`,
   with the flag `--input-type=module`.
 
+* Code that contains syntax that only parses successfully as [ES modules][],
+  such as `import` or `export` statements or `import.meta`, when the code has no
+  explicit marker of how it should be interpreted. Explicit markers are `.mjs`
+  or `.cjs` extensions, `package.json` `"type"` fields with either `"module"` or
+  `"commonjs"` values, or `--input-type` or `--experimental-default-type` flags.
+  Dynamic `import()` expressions are supported in either CommonJS or ES modules
+  and would not cause a file to be treated as an ES module.
+
 Node.js will treat the following as [CommonJS][] when passed to `node` as the
 initial input, or when referenced by `import` statements or `import()`
 expressions:

lib/internal/modules/esm/get_format.js

@@ -18,9 +18,7 @@ const {
 
 const experimentalNetworkImports =
   getOptionValue('--experimental-network-imports');
-const defaultTypeFlag = getOptionValue('--experimental-default-type');
-// The next line is where we flip the default to ES modules someday.
-const defaultType = defaultTypeFlag === 'module' ? 'module' : 'commonjs';
+const { containsModuleSyntax } = internalBinding('contextify');
 const { getPackageType } = require('internal/modules/esm/resolve');
 const { fileURLToPath } = require('internal/url');
 const { ERR_UNKNOWN_FILE_EXTENSION } = require('internal/errors').codes;
@@ -85,42 +83,66 @@ function underNodeModules(url) {
 
 /**
  * @param {URL} url
- * @param {{parentURL: string}} context
+ * @param {{parentURL: string; source?: Buffer}} context
  * @param {boolean} ignoreErrors
  * @returns {string}
  */
-function getFileProtocolModuleFormat(url, context, ignoreErrors) {
+function getFileProtocolModuleFormat(url, context = { __proto__: null }, ignoreErrors) {
+  const { source } = context;
   const ext = extname(url);
 
   if (ext === '.js') {
     const packageType = getPackageType(url);
     if (packageType !== 'none') {
       return packageType;
     }
+
     // The controlling `package.json` file has no `type` field.
-    if (defaultType === 'module') {
-      // An exception to the type flag making ESM the default everywhere is that package scopes under `node_modules`
-      // should retain the assumption that a lack of a `type` field means CommonJS.
-      return underNodeModules(url) ? 'commonjs' : 'module';
+    switch (getOptionValue('--experimental-default-type')) {
+      case 'module': { // The user explicitly passed `--experimental-default-type=module`.
+        // An exception to the type flag making ESM the default everywhere is that package scopes under `node_modules`
+        // should retain the assumption that a lack of a `type` field means CommonJS.
+        return underNodeModules(url) ? 'commonjs' : 'module';
+      }
+      case 'commonjs': { // The user explicitly passed `--experimental-default-type=commonjs`.
+        return 'commonjs';
+      }
+      default: { // The user did not pass `--experimental-default-type`.
+        // `source` is undefined when this is called from `defaultResolve`;
+        // but this gets called again from `defaultLoad`/`defaultLoadSync`.
+        if (source && getOptionValue('--experimental-detect-module')) {
+          return containsModuleSyntax(`${source}`, fileURLToPath(url)) ? 'module' : 'commonjs';
+        }
+        return 'commonjs';
+      }
     }
-    return 'commonjs';
   }
 
   if (ext === '') {
     const packageType = getPackageType(url);
-    if (defaultType === 'commonjs') { // Legacy behavior
-      if (packageType === 'none' || packageType === 'commonjs') {
-        return 'commonjs';
-      } // Else packageType === 'module'
+    if (packageType === 'module') {
       return getFormatOfExtensionlessFile(url);
-    } // Else defaultType === 'module'
-    if (underNodeModules(url)) { // Exception for package scopes under `node_modules`
-      return packageType === 'module' ? getFormatOfExtensionlessFile(url) : 'commonjs';
     }
-    if (packageType === 'none' || packageType === 'module') {
-      return getFormatOfExtensionlessFile(url);
-    } // Else packageType === 'commonjs'
-    return 'commonjs';
+    if (packageType !== 'none') {
+      return packageType; // 'commonjs' or future package types
+    }
+
+    // The controlling `package.json` file has no `type` field.
+    switch (getOptionValue('--experimental-default-type')) {
+      case 'module': { // The user explicitly passed `--experimental-default-type=module`.
+        return underNodeModules(url) ? 'commonjs' : getFormatOfExtensionlessFile(url);
+      }
+      case 'commonjs': { // The user explicitly passed `--experimental-default-type=commonjs`.
+        return 'commonjs';
+      }
+      default: { // The user did not pass `--experimental-default-type`.
+        if (source && getOptionValue('--experimental-detect-module') &&
+          getFormatOfExtensionlessFile(url) === 'module') {
+          return containsModuleSyntax(`${source}`, fileURLToPath(url)) ? 'module' : 'commonjs';
+        }
+        return 'commonjs';
+      }
+    }
   }
 
   const format = extensionFormatMap[ext];

lib/internal/modules/esm/load.js

@@ -33,7 +33,7 @@ const DATA_URL_PATTERN = /^[^/]+\/[^,;]+(?:[^,]*?)(;base64)?,([\s\S]*)$/;
 /**
  * @param {URL} url URL to the module
  * @param {ESModuleContext} context used to decorate error messages
- * @returns {{ responseURL: string, source: string | BufferView }}
+ * @returns {Promise<{ responseURL: string, source: string | BufferView }>}
  */
 async function getSource(url, context) {
   const { protocol, href } = url;
@@ -105,7 +105,7 @@ function getSourceSync(url, context) {
  * @param {LoadContext} context
  * @returns {LoadReturn}
  */
-async function defaultLoad(url, context = kEmptyObject) {
+async function defaultLoad(url, context = { __proto__: null }) {
   let responseURL = url;
   let {
     importAttributes,
@@ -127,19 +127,24 @@ async function defaultLoad(url, context = kEmptyObject) {
 
   throwIfUnsupportedURLScheme(urlInstance, experimentalNetworkImports);
 
-  format ??= await defaultGetFormat(urlInstance, context);
-
-  validateAttributes(url, format, importAttributes);
-
-  if (
-    format === 'builtin' ||
-    format === 'commonjs'
-  ) {
+  if (urlInstance.protocol === 'node:') {
     source = null;
   } else if (source == null) {
     ({ responseURL, source } = await getSource(urlInstance, context));
+    context.source = source;
+  }
+
+  if (format == null || format === 'commonjs') {
+    // Now that we have the source for the module, run `defaultGetFormat` again in case we detect ESM syntax.
+    format = await defaultGetFormat(urlInstance, context);
+  }
+
+  if (format === 'commonjs') {
+    source = null; // Let the CommonJS loader handle it (for now)
   }
 
+  validateAttributes(url, format, importAttributes);
+
   return {
     __proto__: null,
     format,
@@ -178,16 +183,17 @@ function defaultLoadSync(url, context = kEmptyObject) {
 
   throwIfUnsupportedURLScheme(urlInstance, false);
 
-  format ??= defaultGetFormat(urlInstance, context);
-
-  validateAttributes(url, format, importAttributes);
-
-  if (format === 'builtin') {
+  if (urlInstance.protocol === 'node:') {
     source = null;
   } else if (source == null) {
     ({ responseURL, source } = getSourceSync(urlInstance, context));
+    context.source = source;
   }
 
+  format ??= defaultGetFormat(urlInstance, context);
+
+  validateAttributes(url, format, importAttributes);
+
   return {
     __proto__: null,
     format,

lib/internal/modules/run_main.js

@@ -4,6 +4,7 @@ const {
   StringPrototypeEndsWith,
 } = primordials;
 
+const { containsModuleSyntax } = internalBinding('contextify');
 const { getOptionValue } = require('internal/options');
 const path = require('path');
 
@@ -70,7 +71,19 @@ function shouldUseESMLoader(mainPath) {
   const { readPackageScope } = require('internal/modules/package_json_reader');
   const pkg = readPackageScope(mainPath);
   // No need to guard `pkg` as it can only be an object or `false`.
-  return pkg.data?.type === 'module' || getOptionValue('--experimental-default-type') === 'module';
+  switch (pkg.data?.type) {
+    case 'module':
+      return true;
+    case 'commonjs':
+      return false;
+    default: { // No package.json or no `type` field.
+      if (getOptionValue('--experimental-detect-module')) {
+        // If the first argument of `containsModuleSyntax` is undefined, it will read `mainPath` from the file system.
+        return containsModuleSyntax(undefined, mainPath);
+      }
+      return false;
+    }
+  }
 }
 
 /**