MMN

This is the implementation of Moore Machine Network (MMN) introduced in the work "Learning Finite State Representations of Recurrent Policy Networks".

If you find it useful in your research, please cite it using :

@inproceedings{
  koul2018learning,
  title={Learning Finite State Representations of Recurrent Policy Networks},
  author={Anurag Koul and Alan Fern and Sam Greydanus},
  booktitle={International Conference on Learning Representations},
  year={2019},
  url={https://openreview.net/forum?id=S1gOpsCctm},
}

Also, here is the link to the poster presented in the ICLR2019.

Installation

• Python 3.5+
• Pytorch
• gym_x
• To install dependencies:

  pip install -r requirements.txt

Usage

We use main_mce.py , main_tomita.py and main_atari.py for experimenting with Mode Counter Environment(a.k.a Gold Rush) , Tomita Grammar and Atari, respectively.

In the following, we describe usage w.r.t main_atari.py. However, the same would apply for other cases.

Parameters

usage: main_atari.py [-h] [--generate_train_data] [--generate_bn_data]
                     [--generate_max_steps GENERATE_MAX_STEPS] [--gru_train]
                     [--gru_test] [--gru_size GRU_SIZE] [--gru_lr GRU_LR]
                     [--bhx_train] [--ox_train] [--bhx_test] [--ox_test]
                     [--bgru_train] [--bgru_test] [--bhx_size BHX_SIZE]
                     [--bhx_suffix BHX_SUFFIX] [--ox_size OX_SIZE]
                     [--train_epochs TRAIN_EPOCHS] [--batch_size BATCH_SIZE]
                     [--bgru_lr BGRU_LR] [--gru_scratch] [--bx_scratch]
                     [--generate_fsm] [--evaluate_fsm]
                     [--bn_episodes BN_EPISODES] [--bn_epochs BN_EPOCHS]
                     [--no_cuda] [--env ENV] [--env_seed ENV_SEED]
                     [--result_dir RESULT_DIR]

GRU to FSM

optional arguments:
  -h, --help            show this help message and exit
  --generate_train_data
                        Generate Train Data
  --generate_bn_data    Generate Bottle-Neck Data
  --generate_max_steps GENERATE_MAX_STEPS
                        Maximum number of steps to be used for data generation
  --gru_train           Train GRU Network
  --gru_test            Test GRU Network
  --gru_size GRU_SIZE   No. of GRU Cells
  --gru_lr GRU_LR       No. of GRU Cells
  --bhx_train           Train bx network
  --ox_train            Train ox network
  --bhx_test            Test bx network
  --ox_test             Test ox network
  --bgru_train          Train binary gru network
  --bgru_test           Test binary gru network
  --bhx_size BHX_SIZE   binary encoding size
  --bhx_suffix BHX_SUFFIX
                        suffix fo bhx folder
  --ox_size OX_SIZE     binary encoding size
  --train_epochs TRAIN_EPOCHS
                        No. of training episodes
  --batch_size BATCH_SIZE
                        batch size used for training
  --bgru_lr BGRU_LR     Learning rate for binary GRU
  --gru_scratch         use scratch gru for BGRU
  --bx_scratch          use scratch bx network for BGRU
  --generate_fsm        extract fsm from fmm net
  --evaluate_fsm        evaluate fsm
  --bn_episodes BN_EPISODES
                        No. of episodes for generating data for Bottleneck
                        Network
  --bn_epochs BN_EPOCHS
                        No. of Training epochs
  --no_cuda             no cuda usage
  --env ENV             Name of the environment
  --env_seed ENV_SEED   Seed for the environment
  --result_dir RESULT_DIR
                        Directory Path to store results

For most of the experiments we've done, we've set generate_max_steps = 100. Based on the environment you're using, you can change it accordingly. Other parameters' values were set to the default ones, except for ox_size, hx_size, and gru_size which were set based on the experiment we ran.

Use prepared scripts

Formation of MMN requires following multiple steps which could be found here. These steps could also be sequentially executed for bhx_size=64,ox_size=100 using the following script. This script could be easily customized for other environments.

./run_atari.sh PongDeterministic-v4

Steps

1. Test RNN: We assume existence of pre-trained RNN model. The following step is optional and evaluates the performance of this model:

   python main_atari.py --env PongDeterministic-v4 --gru_test --gru_size 32

2. Generate Bottleneck Data: It involves generating and storing data for training quantized bottleneck data (QBN).

   python main_atari.py --env PongDeterministic-v4 --generate_bn_data --gru_size 32 --generate_max_steps 100

3. Train BHX : It involves training QBN for Hidden State (hx). After each epoch, the QBN is inserted into orginal rnn model and the overall model is evaluated with environment. The Best performing QBN is saved.

   python main_atari.py --env PongDeterministic-v4 --bhx_train --bhx_size 64 --gru_size 32 --generate_max_steps 100

   After it's done, the model and plots will be saved here:

   results/Atari/PongDeterministic-v4/gru_32_bhx_64/

4. Test BHX (optional): Inserts the saved BHX model into original rnn model and evaluates the model with environment.

   python main_atari.py --env PongDeterministic-v4 --bhx_test --bhx_size 64 --gru_size 32 --generate_max_steps 100

5. Train OX : It involves training QBN for learned observation features(X) given as input to RNN.

   python main_atari.py --env PongDeterministic-v4 --ox_train --ox_size 100 --bhx_size 64 --gru_size 32 --generate_max_steps 100

   After it's done, the model and plots will be saved here:

   results/Atari/PongDeterministic-v4/gru_32_ox_100/

6. Test BHX (optional): Inserts the saved OX model into original rnn model and evaluates the model with environment.

   python main_atari.py --env PongDeterministic-v4 --ox_test --ox_size 100 --bhx_size 64 --gru_size 32 --generate_max_steps 100

7. MMN: We form the Moore Machine Network by inserting both the BHX and OX qbn's into the original rnn model. Thereafter the performance of the mmn is evaluated on the environment. Fine-Tuning of MMN is performed if there is a fall in performance which could be caused by accumulated error by both the qbn's.

   python main_atari.py --env PongDeterministic-v4 --bgru_train --ox_size 100 --bhx_size 64 --gru_size 32 --generate_max_steps 100

   When the fine-tuning is done, model and plots will be saved here:

   results/Atari/PongDeterministic-v4/gru_32_hx_(64,100)_bgru

8. Test MMN (optional): Loads and tests the saved MMN model.

   python main_atari.py --env PongDeterministic-v4 --bgru_test --bhx_size 64 --ox_size 100 --gru_size 32 --generate_max_steps 100

9. Extract Moore Machine: In this final step, quantized observation and hidden state space are enumarated to form a moore machine. Thereafter minimization is performed on top of it.

   python main_atari.py --env PongDeterministic-v4 --generate_fsm --bhx_size 64 --ox_size 100 --gru_size 32 --generate_max_steps 100

   Final Results before and after minimization are stored in text files (fsm.txt and minimized_moore_machine.txt ) here:

   results/Atari/PongDeterministic-v4/gru_32_hx_(64,100)_bgru/

Using pre-trained models

For results to be easily reproducible, previously trained GRU models on different environments have been provided. You can simply use them to train new QBNs and reproduce the results presented in the paper. Models are accessible through this directory: results/Atari/. The GRU cell size can be determined from the models' path, i.e. if a model is saved in a folder named as gru_32, then the GRU cell size is 32. Having the pretrained GRU model, you can go to how to run the code step by step to start training the QBNs.

Results

MCE

Presenting the Mode Counter Environments(MCE) results, number of states and observations of the MMs extracted from the MMNs both before and after minimization. Moore Machine extraction for MCE(table 1 in paper):

Game	Bh	Bf	Fine-Tuning Score		Before Minimization			After Minimization
			Before(%)	After(%)	|H|	|O|	Acc(%)	|H|	|O|	Acc(%)
Amnesia (gold rush read)	4	4	98	100	7	5	100	4	4	100
	4	8	99	100	7	7	100	4	4	100
	8	4	100	-	6	5	100	4	4	100
	8	8	99	100	7	7	100	4	4	100
Blind (gold rush blind)	4	4	100	-	12	6	100	10	1	100
	4	8	100	-	12	8	100	10	1	100
	8	4	100	-	15	6	100	10	1	100
	8	8	78	100	13	8	100	10	1	100
Tracker (gold rush sneak)	4	4	98	98	58	5	98	50	4	98
	4	8	99	100	23	5	100	10	4	100
	8	4	98	100	91	5	100	10	4	100
	8	8	99	100	85	5	100	10	4	100

Tomita Grammar

The below table presents the test results for the trained RNNs giving the accuracy over a test set of 100 strings drawn from the same distribution as used for training. Moore Machine extraction for Tomita grammar(table 2 in paper):

Grammar	RNN Acc(%)	Bh	Fine-Tuning Score		Before Minimization		After Minimization
			Before(%)	After(%)	|H|	Acc(%)	|H|	Acc(%)
1	100	8	100	-	13	100	2	100
	100	16	100	-	28	100	2	100
2	100	8	100	-	13	100	3	100
	100	16	100	-	14	100	3	100
3	100	8	100	-	34	100	5	100
	100	16	100	-	39	100	5	100
4	100	8	100	-	17	100	4	100
	100	16	100	-	18	100	4	100
5	100	8	95	96	192	96	115	96
	100	16	100	-	316	100	4	100
6	99	8	98	98	100	98	12	98
	99	16	99	99	518	99	11	99
7	100	8	100	-	25	100	5	100
	100	16	100	-	107	100	5	100

Control Tasks

To run the whole thing over control tasks, you only need to run the run_control.sh file. Below, is an example of how to do it:

sh run_control.sh Acrobot-v1 32 64 64

More experiments on control tasks have been done. Results are presented in the following table:

Game(# of actions)	Bh	Bf	Before Minimization			After Minimization
			|H|	|O|	Score	|H|	|O|	Score
Cart Pole(2)	64	64	27	859	500	4	32	500
Lunar Lander(4)	128	64	1502	1165	198	52	89	115
Acrobot(3)	64	64	769	649	-73.95	11	23	-89.4

Atari

This table shows the performance of the trained MMNs before and after finetuning for different combinations of B_h and B_f. A few more games investigated and the results are added to the table 3 of the paper: Results may slightly vary.

Game(# of actions)	RNN(score)	Bh	Bf	Fine-Tuning Score		Before Minimization			After Minimization
				Before	After	|H|	|O|	Score	|H|	|O|	Score
Pong(3)	21	64	100	20	21	380	374	21	4	12	21
		64	400	20	21	373	372	21	3	10	21
		128	100	20	21	383	373	21	3	12	21
		128	400	20	21	379	371	21	3	11	21
Freeway(3)	21	64	100	21	-	1	1	21	1	1	21
		64	400	21	-	1	1	21	1	1	21
		128	100	21	-	1	1	21	1	1	21
		128	400	21	-	1	1	21	1	1	21
Breakout(4)	773	64	100	32	423	1898	1874	423	8	30	423
		64	400	25	415	1888	1871	415	8	30	415
		128	100	41	377	1583	1514	377	11	27	377
		128	400	85	379	1729	1769	379	8	30	379
Space Invaders(4)	1820	64	100	520	1335	1495	1502	1335	8	29	1335
		64	400	365	1235	1625	1620	1235	12	29	1235
		128	100	390	1040	1563	1457	1040	12	35	1040
		128	400	520	1430	1931	1921	1430	6	27	1430
Bowling(6)	60	64	100	60	-	49	1	60	33	1	60
		64	400	60	-	49	1	60	33	1	60
		128	100	60	-	26	1	60	24	1	60
		128	400	60	-	26	1	60	24	1	60
Boxing(18)	100	64	100	94	100	1173	1167	100	13	79	100
		64	400	98	100	2621	2605	100	14	119	100
		128	100	94	97	2499	2482	97	14	106	97
		128	400	97	100	1173	1169	100	14	88	100
Chopper Command(18)	5300	64	100		4000	3710	3731	4000	38	182	1890