Problem: ica packet callback doesn't contain channel detail #1235
Conversation
|
The existing content is comprehensive and aligns with the provided instructions. Therefore, no modifications are necessary. TipsChat with CodeRabbit Bot (
|
Codecov Report
Additional details and impacted files@@ Coverage Diff @@
## main #1235 +/- ##
===========================================
+ Coverage 16.67% 36.81% +20.13%
===========================================
Files 79 115 +36
Lines 5786 10287 +4501
===========================================
+ Hits 965 3787 +2822
- Misses 4743 6126 +1383
- Partials 78 374 +296
|
mmsqe
requested review from
JayT106 and
calvinaco
and removed request for
a team
![coderabbitai[bot]](https://avatars.githubusercontent.com/in/347564?s=60&v=4){kind=small}
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Review Status
Actionable comments generated: 0
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Files selected for processing (6)
- CHANGELOG.md (1 hunks)
- integration_tests/contracts/contracts/TestICA.sol (2 hunks)
- integration_tests/test_ica_precompile.py (6 hunks)
- x/cronos/events/bindings/cosmos/precompile/icacallback/i_ica_callback.abigen.go (2 hunks)
- x/cronos/events/bindings/src/ICACallback.sol (1 hunks)
- x/cronos/keeper/keeper.go (1 hunks)
Additional comments: 14
x/cronos/keeper/keeper.go (1)
- 292-298: The
onPacketResultfunction has been updated to includepacket.SourceChannelas a parameter in theOnPacketResultCallbackfunction call. Ensure that all calls to this function throughout the codebase have been updated to match the new signature.CHANGELOG.md (1)
- 16-16: The change log entry is clear and links to the relevant pull request. Ensure that the pull request contains all the necessary information for future reference.
x/cronos/events/bindings/src/ICACallback.sol (1)
- 2-6: The change in the function signature of
onPacketResultCallbackis correctly reflected. Ensure that all calls to this function throughout the codebase have been updated to match the new signature.integration_tests/contracts/contracts/TestICA.sol (3)
15-19: The change from a single mapping to a nested mapping allows tracking of packet status across multiple channels. This is a significant change and should be tested thoroughly to ensure it works as expected.
105-107: The
getStatusfunction is a new addition that retrieves the status of a packet based on its source channel and sequence number. Ensure that it is being used correctly in the rest of the codebase.109-118: The
onPacketResultCallbackfunction now includespacketSrcChannelas a parameter and updates the status accordingly. This is a significant change and should be tested thoroughly to ensure it works as expected.integration_tests/test_ica_precompile.py (4)
170-178: The
wait_for_status_changefunction now accepts a new parameterchannel_id. Ensure that all calls to this function throughout the codebase have been updated to match the new signature.198-210: The
register_accfunction call now includeschannel_idas a parameter. Ensure that the function definition has been updated to accept this new parameter.316-317: The
wait_for_status_changefunction calls now includechannel_idas a parameter. This is consistent with the updated function definition.271-272: The
submit_msgs_rofunction calls have been updated to include thechannel_idparameter. Ensure that the function definition has been updated to accept this new parameter.x/cronos/events/bindings/cosmos/precompile/icacallback/i_ica_callback.abigen.go (4)
30-34: The ABI for the
onPacketResultCallbackfunction has been updated to include thepacketSrcChannelparameter. Ensure that all calls to this function throughout the codebase have been updated to match the new signature.182-187: The
OnPacketResultCallbackfunction in theICACallbackTransactorstruct has been updated to include thepacketSrcChannelparameter. Ensure that all calls to this function throughout the codebase have been updated to match the new signature.189-194: The
OnPacketResultCallbackfunction in theICACallbackSessionstruct has been updated to include thepacketSrcChannelparameter. Ensure that all calls to this function throughout the codebase have been updated to match the new signature.196-201: The
OnPacketResultCallbackfunction in theICACallbackTransactorSessionstruct has been updated to include thepacketSrcChannelparameter. Ensure that all calls to this function throughout the codebase have been updated to match the new signature.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Review Status
Actionable comments generated: 0
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Files selected for processing (2)
- integration_tests/contracts/contracts/TestICA.sol (2 hunks)
- integration_tests/test_ica_precompile.py (6 hunks)
Additional comments: 8
integration_tests/contracts/contracts/TestICA.sol (5)
15-17: The
Statusenum has been defined correctly and is being used appropriately in the code.18-18: The
statusMaphas been updated to use a nested mapping with a string key. This allows for tracking the status of packets across multiple channels.19-19: The
OnPacketResultevent now includes a string parameter for packet source channel. This allows for better tracking of packet statuses across multiple channels.105-107: The
getStatusfunction has been added to retrieve the status based on the packet source channel and sequence number. This function is correctly implemented and should work as expected.109-119: The
onPacketResultCallbackfunction has been updated to includepacketSrcChannelas a parameter and update the status accordingly. This function is correctly implemented and should work as expected.integration_tests/test_ica_precompile.py (3)
171-179: The
wait_for_status_changefunction now includes achannel_idparameter. This change seems to be related to incorporating channel-specific information into the function for handling status changes.182-185: The
assert_packet_resultfunction's signature has been updated to include thechannel_idparameter. This change seems to be related to incorporating channel-specific information into the function for handling packet results.198-210: The
channel_idis now passed to theregister_accfunction. This change seems to be related to incorporating channel-specific information into the function for registering accounts.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Review Status
Actionable comments generated: 0
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Files selected for processing (1)
- integration_tests/test_ica_precompile.py (6 hunks)
Additional comments: 7
integration_tests/test_ica_precompile.py (7)
171-179: The
wait_for_status_changefunction now accepts achannel_idparameter and uses it to check the status. This change is likely to support multiple channels.182-186: The
assert_packet_resultfunction now accepts achannel_idparameter and includes it in the expected result. This change is likely to support assertions for multiple channels.199-211: The
channel_idparameter is now included in theregister_accfunction call within thetest_sc_callfunction. This change is likely to support testing for multiple channels.254-260: The
channel_idparameter is now included in thewait_for_status_change,getStatus, andassert_packet_resultfunction calls within thetest_sc_callfunction. These changes are likely to support testing for multiple channels.274-281: The
channel_idparameter is now included in thewait_for_status_change,getStatus, andassert_packet_resultfunction calls within thetest_sc_callfunction. These changes are likely to support testing for multiple channels.296-303: The
channel_idparameter is now included in thewait_for_status_change,getStatus, andassert_packet_resultfunction calls within thetest_sc_callfunction. These changes are likely to support testing for multiple channels.317-323: The
channel_idparameter is now included in thewait_for_status_change,getStatus, andassert_packet_resultfunction calls within thetest_sc_callfunction. These changes are likely to support testing for multiple channels.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Review Status
Actionable comments generated: 0
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Files selected for processing (1)
- integration_tests/test_ica_precompile.py (6 hunks)
Additional comments: 8
integration_tests/test_ica_precompile.py (8)
172-180: The
wait_for_status_changefunction has been updated to include achannel_idparameter, which is used to check the status of a packet based on the channel. This is a necessary change to accommodate the new functionality of tracking packets across multiple channels.183-188: The
wait_for_packet_logfunction has also been updated to include achannel_idparameter. This change ensures that the function waits for a packet log that matches both the sequence number and the channel, aligning with the new event structure.260-266: The
wait_for_status_changeandwait_for_packet_logfunctions are called with thechannel_idparameter, reflecting the changes made to their definitions. This is consistent with the pull request's goal to include channel information in the packet callback functionality.281-287: Similar to the previous hunk, the
wait_for_status_changeandwait_for_packet_logfunctions are called with thechannel_idparameter. The assertions check that the sequence number and status are as expected, which is crucial for the integrity of the packet handling logic.303-308: Again, the
wait_for_status_changeandwait_for_packet_logfunctions are used correctly with thechannel_idparameter. The assertion that the status isStatus.FAILindicates that the test is checking for a failure condition, which is an important part of testing the robustness of the system.326-332: The
wait_for_status_change,wait_for_packet_log, andwait_for_check_channel_readyfunctions are called with thechannel_idparameter. The assertion that the status isStatus.FAILand the check for the channel state being closed are important validations for the test.334-345: A new
channel_id2variable is introduced and used in thesubmit_msgsfunction call. This is consistent with the pull request's description, which mentions the introduction of a new variable to handle multiple channels. The assertions ensure that the new channel ID is different from the previous one and that the ICA address remains the same, which is a logical expectation for the test scenario.359-364: The
wait_for_packet_logfunction is called withchannel_id2, which is the new channel variable introduced earlier. This ensures that the test is waiting for the packet log on the correct channel. The balance assertion checks that the funds have been correctly processed, which is a key part of the test.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Review Status
Actionable comments generated: 1
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Files selected for processing (1)
- integration_tests/test_ica_precompile.py (6 hunks)
Additional comments: 6
integration_tests/test_ica_precompile.py (6)
172-179: The
wait_for_status_changefunction now requires achannel_idparameter to check the status for a specific channel. This is a logical change given the context of IBC where multiple channels can exist. Ensure that all calls to this function have been updated to pass thechannel_idparameter.182-187: The
wait_for_packet_logfunction has been updated to include achannel_idparameter, which is used to filter the logs for a specific channel. This change is consistent with the need to handle multiple channels in IBC. However, the actual filtering logic based onchannel_idis not visible in the provided hunk. Ensure that the implementation ofcheck_logwithinwait_for_packet_logcorrectly filters logs based on thechannel_id.256-265: The
submit_msgs_rofunction is called with astrparameter, which is expected to be the packet data. Thewait_for_status_changeandwait_for_packet_logfunctions are then used to wait for the status change and packet log, respectively. The balance is checked after these operations to ensure it matches the expected balance. This hunk shows the correct usage of the newchannel_idparameter in thewait_for_status_changeandwait_for_packet_logfunctions.277-286: Similar to the previous hunk, this hunk also demonstrates the correct usage of the
channel_idparameter in thewait_for_status_changeandwait_for_packet_logfunctions. The assertions check that the sequence and status are as expected, and the balance is verified.299-307: This hunk handles the case where a transaction fails. The
wait_for_status_changeandwait_for_packet_logfunctions are used to wait for the status change and packet log, respectively, and the balance is checked to ensure it has not changed due to the failed transaction. This is the correct behavior as the balance should remain the same if the transaction fails.322-345: This hunk shows the handling of a timeout scenario and the registration of a new channel with
channel_id2. It is important to ensure that theget_next_channelfunction correctly retrieves a new channel ID and that theregister_accfunction behaves as expected with the new channel. The assertions check that the new channel ID is different from the previous one and that the ICA address remains the same, which may or may not be the intended behavior depending on the system's design. Verify that the ICA address should indeed be the same for different channels.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Review Status
Actionable comments generated: 0
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Files selected for processing (1)
- integration_tests/test_ica_precompile.py (7 hunks)
Additional comments: 8
integration_tests/test_ica_precompile.py (8)
173-180: The
wait_for_status_changefunction now accepts achannel_idparameter, which is used to check the status for a specific channel. This is a good update for handling multiple channels. However, ensure that all calls to this function have been updated to pass the newchannel_idparameter.183-193: The
wait_for_packet_logfunction has been updated to include thechannel_idparameter. Thekeccakfunction is used to hash thechannel_idbefore comparing it with the expected log. This change is consistent with the need to handle channel-specific logs. Ensure that the hashing ofchannel_idis the expected behavior and that all consumers of this function are aware of this change.---end hunk 1---
---start hunk 2---
- 266-272: The
wait_for_status_changeandwait_for_packet_logfunctions are called with thechannel_idandlast_seqto wait for the status change and packet log, respectively. The assertions check if the status isStatus.SUCCESSand if the balance after the transaction matches the expected balance. This hunk shows the correct usage of the updated functions with the newchannel_idparameter.---end hunk 2---
---start hunk 3---
- 289-293: Similar to the previous hunk, this code block is using the updated functions with the
channel_idparameter correctly. The assertions ensure the status and balance are as expected.---end hunk 3---
---start hunk 4---
- 312-314: The
wait_for_status_changeandwait_for_packet_logfunctions are used to check for aStatus.FAILafter submitting messages that are expected to fail. The balance check ensures that the balance remains unchanged, which is the expected behavior in case of failure. This hunk is consistent with the intended functionality.---end hunk 4---
---start hunk 5---
335-337: The code waits for a
Status.FAILdue to a timeout and checks that the balance remains unchanged. This is consistent with the expected behavior when a timeout occurs.338-351: The
wait_for_check_channel_readyfunction is called with a newchannel_id2, which is obtained by callingget_next_channel. Theregister_accfunction is then called withchannel_id2, and assertions are made to ensure thatchannel_id2is different from the originalchannel_idand that theica_address2is the same as the originalica_address. This suggests that the same ICA account is expected to be used across different channels. Ensure that this is the intended behavior and that theregister_accfunction is designed to handle this scenario.---end hunk 5---
---start hunk 6---
- 363-370: The
wait_for_status_changeandwait_for_packet_logfunctions are called withchannel_id2, which is the new channel ID introduced in the previous hunk. The assertions check forStatus.SUCCESSand the expected balance, indicating that the functions are being used correctly with the new channel ID.---end hunk 6---
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Review Status
Actionable comments generated: 2
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Files selected for processing (8)
- app/app.go (2 hunks)
- integration_tests/test_ica_precompile.py (11 hunks)
- x/cronos/events/bindings/cosmos/precompile/ica/i_ica_module.abigen.go (3 hunks)
- x/cronos/events/bindings/src/ICA.sol (1 hunks)
- x/cronos/events/events.go (1 hunks)
- x/cronos/keeper/precompiles/ica.go (3 hunks)
- x/cronos/types/interfaces.go (1 hunks)
- x/icaauth/keeper/keeper.go (5 hunks)
Files skipped from review due to trivial changes (1)
- x/cronos/events/bindings/src/ICA.sol
Additional comments: 28
x/cronos/types/interfaces.go (1)
- 87-91: The
SubmitTxWithArgsmethod signature has been updated to return an additional string value. Ensure that all implementations of theIcaauthkeeperinterface and calls toSubmitTxWithArgsare updated to handle the new return value. This change may have implications on error handling and result processing logic in the code that uses this interface.x/cronos/events/events.go (1)
- 35-40: The addition of
channeltypes.AttributeKeySrcChanneltoIcaValueDecodersmap is consistent with the pull request's goal to track channel-specific packet status. This change will allow the system to decode the source channel attribute from ICA packets.x/cronos/keeper/precompiles/ica.go (3)
11-17: The import section has been updated to include the
channeltypespackage, which is used for handling IBC channel-related information. This change is consistent with the pull request's goal of enhancing ICA packet handling by incorporating channel details.182-188: The
SubmitTxWithArgsfunction call has been modified to return an additional value,activeChannelID. This change should be verified across the codebase to ensure that all calls to this function handle the new return value correctly.194-200: The event emitted now includes a new attribute for the source channel (
channeltypes.AttributeKeySrcChannel). This is a key change that aligns with the pull request's objective to include channel information in packet status tracking. Ensure that the event consumers are updated to handle this new attribute.app/app.go (2)
- 637-643: > Note: This review was outside of the patch, so it was mapped to the patch with the greatest overlap. Original lines [637-651]
The changes to the
Appstruct initialization include the addition ofscopedICAControllerKeeperto theICAAuthKeeperand the use ofWithICS4Wrappermethod withicaControllerStack. These changes are critical for the correct initialization of theicaauthkeepermodule with the new channel information. Ensure that theicaControllerStackis correctly initialized and that theWithICS4Wrappermethod is called with the appropriate arguments. Also, verify that theicaControllerStackis being used correctly in the IBC router setup.
- 646-651: The middleware stack for the ICA controller is being set up with the
ibcfeemiddleware and theibccallbacksmiddleware. It is important to ensure that the middleware stack is correctly configured and that the order of middleware is appropriate for the desired behavior. The use ofmath.MaxUint64as the gas limit for theibccallbacksmiddleware should be reviewed to ensure it aligns with the intended gas usage policies.x/cronos/events/bindings/cosmos/precompile/ica/i_ica_module.abigen.go (4)
31-34: The ABI string has been updated to reflect the new event signature with the
packetSrcChannelparameter. This change should be verified to ensure that it matches the actual smart contract ABI after the contract has been deployed or updated.330-343: The
FilterSubmitMsgsResultfunction has been updated to filter logs based on thepacketSrcChannel. Ensure that the providedpacketSrcChannelslice is correctly handled and that the filtering works as expected with the updated event signature.346-359: The
WatchSubmitMsgsResultfunction has been updated similarly toFilterSubmitMsgsResult. It should be verified that the subscription to the event logs works correctly with the newpacketSrcChannelparameter.388-393: The
ParseSubmitMsgsResultfunction has been updated to parse logs for theSubmitMsgsResultevent. It is important to verify that the log parsing correctly handles the newpacketSrcChannelparameter and that the function behaves as expected when invoked.x/icaauth/keeper/keeper.go (5)
28-34: The addition of
ics4WrapperandcontrollerScopedKeeperfields to theKeeperstruct is consistent with the need to handle channel information. Ensure that all necessary nil checks and initializations for these new fields are in place wherever theKeeperstruct is used.56-58: The
WithICS4Wrappermethod is a good use of the builder pattern, allowing for theics4Wrapperto be set post-construction of theKeeperobject. This can be useful for dependency injection and testing.73-125: > Note: This review was outside of the patch, so it was mapped to the patch with the greatest overlap. Original lines [60-77]
The
SubmitTxmethod has been updated to return a response and an error, which is a good practice for error handling. Ensure that all callers of this method handle the returned error appropriately.
80-104: The
sendTxmethod includes comprehensive error handling and returns detailed errors, which is good for debugging and error tracking. However, ensure that the error messages do not expose sensitive information that could be a security risk.106-125: The
SubmitTxWithArgsmethod now returns an additional string representing the active channel ID, which is necessary for the new channel-specific packet status tracking. Ensure that all callers of this method are updated to handle the new return value.General note:
Ensure that the new error handling and return values do not introduce any breaking changes to existing functionality and that all dependent modules are updated accordingly.integration_tests/test_ica_precompile.py (12)
3-9: The import of
keccakfrometh_utilsis correctly placed according to PEP 8 import order standards, which recommend standard library imports first, followed by third-party imports, and then local application/library specific imports.80-84: The
channel_idparameter has been correctly added to thesubmit_msgsfunction signature to accommodate the new requirement for channel-specific packet status tracking. However, ensure that all calls to this function are updated to pass thechannel_idargument.120-131: The use of
keccakto hash thechannel_idis appropriate if the intention is to have a fixed-length, unique identifier for the channel in the logs. However, ensure that theexpected_seqis being correctly set and used in the context where this function is called. Also, verify that theevent.getLogs()method is compatible with the expected structure of the logs after the addition of thepacketSrcChannelparameter.140-152: The
register_accfunction has been updated to accept thechannel_idparameter. This is consistent with the pull request's goal to include channel information in the ICA packet handling. Ensure that thechannel_idis being correctly retrieved and passed to this function in all relevant parts of the code.160-166: The
submit_msgsfunction is called with the newchannel_idparameter, which is correctly passed to the function. This change is necessary for the function to work with the updated logic that includes channel information.173-179: Again, the
submit_msgsfunction is called with thechannel_idparameter. It's important to ensure that theexpected_seqis managed correctly across different calls to maintain the integrity of the sequence tracking.182-202: The new
wait_for_status_changeandwait_for_packet_logfunctions are introduced to wait for a status change and packet log, respectively, with thechannel_idparameter included. This is a necessary addition to handle the channel-specific packet status tracking. Ensure that thetcontract.caller.getStatusandevent.getLogs()methods are correctly implemented to handle thechannel_idparameter.268-282: The
submit_msgs_rofunction is called with thechannel_idparameter, which is correctly passed to the function. This change is necessary for the function to work with the updated logic that includes channel information.290-304: The
submit_msgs_rofunction is called again with thechannel_idparameter. Ensure that theexpected_seqis managed correctly across different calls to maintain the integrity of the sequence tracking.315-326: The
submit_msgsfunction is called with a largeamountparameter, which seems to be intended to test the failure case. Ensure that theStatus.FAILis the expected status when theamountexceeds a certain threshold and that this behavior is documented and tested.339-365: The
submit_msgsfunction is called with atimeoutparameter to test the timeout case. Ensure that theStatus.FAILis the expected status when a timeout occurs and that this behavior is documented and tested. Also, verify that thewait_for_check_channel_readyfunction correctly handles thechannel_idparameter and that theSTATE_CLOSEDstate is the expected state after a timeout.371-384: The
submit_msgsfunction is called with a newchannel_id2parameter, which is correctly passed to the function. This change is necessary for the function to work with the updated logic that includes channel information. Ensure that thechannel_id2is being correctly retrieved and passed to this function in all relevant parts of the code.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Review Status
Actionable comments generated: 3
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Files selected for processing (8)
- app/app.go (2 hunks)
- integration_tests/test_ica_precompile.py (11 hunks)
- x/cronos/events/bindings/cosmos/precompile/ica/i_ica_module.abigen.go (3 hunks)
- x/cronos/events/bindings/src/ICA.sol (1 hunks)
- x/cronos/events/events.go (1 hunks)
- x/cronos/keeper/precompiles/ica.go (3 hunks)
- x/cronos/types/interfaces.go (1 hunks)
- x/icaauth/keeper/keeper.go (5 hunks)
Additional comments: 28
x/cronos/events/bindings/cosmos/precompile/ica/i_ica_module.abigen.go (1)
- 31-34: The ABI string for the
SubmitMsgsResultevent has been updated to include thepacketSrcChannelparameter. Ensure that all dependent systems and integrations are updated to handle the new event structure.x/cronos/events/bindings/src/ICA.sol (1)
- 2-8: The addition of
packetSrcChannelto theSubmitMsgsResultevent is a significant change that will affect any off-chain services or contracts that listen to this event. Ensure that all listeners are updated to handle the new indexed parameter.x/cronos/events/events.go (1)
- 35-40: The addition of
channeltypes.AttributeKeySrcChanneltoIcaValueDecodersaligns with the pull request's goal to include channel information in the ICA packet callback. This change ensures that the source channel attribute is correctly decoded when ICA events are processed.x/cronos/keeper/precompiles/ica.go (3)
11-17: The import section has been updated to include the
channeltypespackage, which is necessary for the new functionality related to channel information in IBC packets.182-188: > Note: This review was outside of the patch, so it was mapped to the patch with the greatest overlap. Original lines [182-200]
The
Runfunction within theIcaContracttype has been updated to handle theSubmitMsgsMethodNamecase. It now captures theactiveChannelIDfrom theSubmitTxWithArgsfunction call and emits it as part of an event. This change is crucial for tracking the channel information of IBC packets and aligns with the pull request's goal to include channel detail in the ICA packet callback.However, ensure that the
activeChannelIDis being correctly retrieved and that theSubmitTxWithArgsfunction is updated accordingly to return this new piece of information.
- 194-200: The event emission has been modified to include the
channeltypes.AttributeKeySrcChannelattribute with theactiveChannelID. This is a necessary change for the event to carry the new channel information. Ensure that all event consumers are updated to handle this new attribute.app/app.go (3)
- 637-643: > Note: This review was outside of the patch, so it was mapped to the patch with the greatest overlap. Original lines [637-651]
The
WithICS4Wrappermethod is now being used to set theics4Wrapperfor bothICAControllerKeeperandICAAuthKeeper. This is a significant change as it affects the middleware stack for IBC transactions. Ensure that the middleware stack is correctly configured and that theics4Wrapperis properly integrated into the IBC transaction flow.
646-651: The
WithICS4Wrappermethod is being called with a type assertion toporttypes.Middleware. Ensure that theicaControllerStackis guaranteed to implementporttypes.Middlewareto prevent potential runtime panics due to failed type assertions.651-651: The
math.MaxUint64is being used to indicate no gas limit for theibccallbacks.NewIBCMiddleware. This could potentially allow transactions to consume an unlimited amount of gas, which may not be desirable. Verify that this is the intended behavior and consider implementing a reasonable gas limit if necessary.x/icaauth/keeper/keeper.go (7)
14-22: The addition of
clienttypesandporttypespackages indicates new dependencies for theKeeperstruct. Ensure that these new dependencies are properly managed and do not introduce any circular dependencies.28-34: The introduction of
ics4WrapperandcontrollerScopedKeeperfields to theKeeperstruct suggests an expansion of theKeeper's responsibilities. Verify that these fields are being used appropriately and that their lifecycle is managed correctly.41-53: The
NewKeeperfunction's signature has been modified to include thecontrollerScopedKeeperparameter. Ensure that all instantiations ofKeeperthroughout the codebase are updated to provide this new argument.56-58: The
WithICS4Wrappermethod has been added to set theics4Wrapperfield on theKeeperstruct. This method should be called before theKeeperis used if theics4Wrapperis required for its operations.73-141: > Note: This review was outside of the patch, so it was mapped to the patch with the greatest overlap. Original lines [60-94]
The
SubmitTxmethod has been updated to include theportIDparameter and use theics4Wrapperfield. Ensure that theportIDis being validated before use and that error handling is robust, especially since this method interacts with external systems (IBC packets).
96-120: The new
sendTxmethod handles the sending of transactions. It's important to ensure that the error handling is comprehensive, given that this method interacts with IBC and capabilities which can fail in various ways.122-141: The
SubmitTxWithArgsmethod now returns an additional string representing the active channel ID. Ensure that the return value is being handled correctly wherever this method is called.General:
The changes made across the file are significant and touch on several core functionalities of theKeeper. It's crucial to ensure that these changes are accompanied by thorough testing, especially integration tests that can simulate real-world usage of the IBC and capability features.integration_tests/test_ica_precompile.py (12)
6-6: The import of
keccakfrometh_utilsis correct and relevant for the cryptographic operations being performed in the code.80-84: The
channel_idparameter has been added to thesubmit_msgsfunction signature to accommodate the new requirement for channel information. This is consistent with the pull request summary.120-130: The use of
keccakto hash thechannel_idwhen asserting the log arguments is correct and ensures that the channel ID is being processed in a consistent manner throughout the system. However, ensure that thechannel_idis in the correct format before hashing, askeccakexpects a string input.140-152: The
register_accfunction has been updated to include thechannel_idparameter, which is used in the registration process. This change is in line with the pull request summary.160-166: The
submit_msgsfunction call now includes thechannel_idparameter, which is passed to the function correctly.173-179: Again, the
submit_msgsfunction call includes thechannel_idparameter, indicating that the changes are consistently applied across the test cases.182-202: The new
wait_for_status_changeandwait_for_packet_logfunctions are designed to wait for a status change and packet log based on thechannel_idand sequence number. This is a necessary addition to handle the new channel-based packet tracking.268-282: The
submit_msgs_rofunction is correctly called with thechannel_idparameter, and the subsequent logic checks for the expected sequence and status, which is consistent with the changes described in the pull request summary.290-304: The
submit_msgs_rofunction is called again with thechannel_idparameter, and the logic is consistent with the previous test case.315-326: The test case here is checking for a failure condition, and the
channel_idparameter is used as expected. The balance check at the end ensures that the balance remains unchanged in case of failure, which is the correct behavior.339-365: The
submit_msgsfunction is called with a timeout and a larger number of messages, and thechannel_idparameter is used as expected. The subsequent checks for the last sequence and status are consistent with the other test cases.371-384: The
submit_msgsfunction is called with a differentchannel_id2, and the test case ensures that the new channel ID is different from the previous one and that the status change and packet log are handled correctly.
![github-advanced-security[bot]](https://avatars.githubusercontent.com/in/57789?s=60&v=4){kind=small}
| } | ||
| minTimeoutDuration := k.MinTimeoutDuration(ctx) | ||
| // timeoutDuration should be constraited by MinTimeoutDuration parameter. | ||
| timeoutTimestamp := ctx.BlockTime().Add( | ||
| types.MsgSubmitTx{ | ||
| TimeoutDuration: &timeoutDuration, | ||
| }.CalculateTimeoutDuration(minTimeoutDuration)).UnixNano() | ||
| res, err := k.icaControllerKeeper.SendTx(ctx, nil, connectionId, portID, packetData, uint64(timeoutTimestamp)) //nolint:staticcheck | ||
| activeChannelID, res, err := k.sendTx(ctx, connectionId, portID, packetData, uint64(timeoutTimestamp)) |
Check failure
Code scanning / gosec
Potential integer overflow by integer type conversion Error
| return "", 0, errorsmod.Wrapf(capabilitytypes.ErrCapabilityNotFound, "failed to find capability: %s", host.ChannelCapabilityPath(portID, activeChannelID)) | ||
| } | ||
|
|
||
| if uint64(ctx.BlockTime().UnixNano()) >= timeoutTimestamp { |
Check failure
Code scanning / gosec
Potential integer overflow by integer type conversion Error
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Review Status
Actionable comments generated: 3
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Files selected for processing (4)
- CHANGELOG.md (1 hunks)
- app/app.go (1 hunks)
- x/icaauth/keeper/keeper.go (5 hunks)
- x/icaauth/module.go (2 hunks)
Additional comments: 8
CHANGELOG.md (1)
- 13-17: The changelog correctly documents the state machine breaking changes for the pull requests Problem: require gas in relayer precompile is higher than consumed #1232 and Problem: ica packet callback doesn't contain channel detail #1235. It is important to ensure that these changes are communicated clearly to developers and users since they may require actions like updating client code or performing network upgrades.
x/icaauth/module.go (2)
11-17: The import statement for
porttypeshas been added correctly. Ensure that the package is used elsewhere in the codebase to justify the import.105-113: The
NewAppModulefunction now takes an additionalics4Wrapperparameter of typeporttypes.ICS4Wrapper. This change requires that all instantiations ofAppModulethroughout the codebase be updated to provide this new argument. Additionally, thekeeper.WithICS4Wrapper(ics4Wrapper)method call is made before theAppModulestruct is returned, which is a good practice to ensure that the keeper is properly configured before use.x/icaauth/keeper/keeper.go (3)
56-58: The
WithICS4Wrappermethod is a good example of the builder pattern, allowing for the optional setting of theics4Wrapper. This is a common pattern in Go for configuring objects after instantiation.80-104: The
sendTxfunction correctly checks for the existence of an active channel and the capability before sending a packet. It also validates the timeout timestamp and packet data, which are good practices for error handling and data validation.106-125: The
SubmitTxWithArgsfunction now returns an additional string representing the active channel ID. Ensure that all callers of this function are updated to handle the new return value.app/app.go (2)
637-653: The staking hooks are being set up, and the
ICAAuthKeeperandICAControllerKeeperare being configured with an ICS4 wrapper. This is part of the middleware stack for IBC (Inter-Blockchain Communication) which is crucial for the correct functioning of the IBC modules. It's important to ensure that the middleware stack is correctly configured and that the order of middleware is appropriate for the application's requirements.640-652: The
ICAAuthKeeperis being initialized with thescopedICAAuthKeeperandscopedICAControllerKeeper. TheicaControllerStackis being wrapped with theibcfeemiddleware and theics4Wrapperis being set for both theICAAuthKeeperandICAControllerKeeper. This is a critical part of the IBC middleware setup and should be reviewed carefully to ensure that the middleware is correctly applied and that theics4Wrapperis correctly implemented.The code is complex and touches on many aspects of the Cosmos SDK and IBC module. It's important to ensure that the changes are thoroughly tested, especially since they involve critical functionality like IBC which is used for communication between different blockchain networks. Additionally, the changes should be reviewed for security, performance, and correctness by someone with expertise in Cosmos SDK and IBC development.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Review Status
Actionable comments generated: 0
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Files selected for processing (1)
- CHANGELOG.md (1 hunks)
Additional comments: 1
CHANGELOG.md (1)
- 13-17: The changelog entries for pull requests Problem: require gas in relayer precompile is higher than consumed #1232 and Problem: ica packet callback doesn't contain channel detail #1235 correctly reflect the changes made to the system. It's important to ensure that the descriptions are accurate and provide enough context for users to understand the impact of the changes. If these pull requests introduce breaking changes, it would be beneficial to highlight this in the changelog for users to take necessary precautions when updating.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Review Status
Actionable comments generated: 1
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Files selected for processing (1)
- integration_tests/test_ica_precompile.py (12 hunks)
Additional comments: 10
integration_tests/test_ica_precompile.py (10)
120-130: The logic here is checking for the presence of logs and then asserting that the first log matches the expected
packetSrcChannelandseq. However, there is a potential issue with the use ofkeccak(text=channel_id); ifchannel_idis an empty string (which is the default value from the previous hunk), this will always hash to the same value, which might not be the intended behavior. Ensure thatchannel_idis always a meaningful string when calling this function.140-152: The
register_accfunction is updated to includechannel_idas a parameter, which is good for supporting multiple channels. However, ensure that all calls to this function have been updated accordingly to pass the newchannel_idparameter.160-166: The
submit_msgsfunction is called with thechannel_idparameter, which is correctly passed down to handle multiple channels. This is a good update for supporting multi-channel functionality.182-203: The
wait_for_status_changeandwait_for_packet_logfunctions have been updated to include thechannel_idparameter. This is necessary for the functions to work with the updatedsubmit_msgsfunction and to support multiple channels. Ensure that all calls to these functions are updated to include the newchannel_idparameter.260-265: The
submit_msgs_rofunction is introduced, which seems to be a read-only version ofsubmit_msgs. However, the function is not defined in the provided code. Ensure that this function is defined elsewhere in the codebase and that it behaves as expected for read-only operations.270-284: The
submit_msgs_rofunction is called twice with differentfuncparameters. This is likely intended to test different read-only submission methods. Ensure that thefuncparameters passed here are intended to be read-only and that thesubmit_msgs_rofunction is defined and behaves correctly.293-307: The
submit_msgsfunction is called again with different parameters, and thesubmit_msgs_rofunction is called twice more. This pattern is consistent with the previous hunk, suggesting that these calls are part of a test sequence. Ensure that the test sequence is complete and covers all necessary cases.319-330: The
submit_msgsfunction is called with a very largeamountparameter, which seems to be intended to test the failure case. This is a good test to ensure that the system behaves correctly when transactions fail due to insufficient funds.344-370: The
submit_msgsfunction is called with atimeoutparameter to test the timeout behavior. This is another good test case. However, ensure that thetimeoutvalue is appropriate for the test environment and that thewait_for_status_changeandwait_for_packet_logfunctions are capable of handling the timeout case correctly.377-390: The
submit_msgsfunction is called with a newchannel_id2, which seems to be testing the behavior of the system with a different channel. This is a good test to ensure that the system can handle multiple channels correctly. Ensure thatchannel_id2is correctly initialized and different fromchannel_idto properly test multi-channel functionality.
👮🏻👮🏻👮🏻 !!!! REFERENCE THE PROBLEM YOUR ARE SOLVING IN THE PR TITLE AND DESCRIBE YOUR SOLUTION HERE !!!! DO NOT FORGET !!!! 👮🏻👮🏻👮🏻
PR Checklist:
make)make test)go fmt)golangci-lint run)go list -json -m all | nancy sleuth)Thank you for your code, it's appreciated! :)
Summary by CodeRabbit
New Features
Style