-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 440
Default search engines that were removed are being reverted to region defaults #920
Comments
Don't think this is a blocker or expected behaviour. Since user sets a different SE which is not on approved list, we should not retain it, reason being iOS doesn't allow adding/removing SE similar to b-c. We should only use the list of approved SE list irrespective of what is set. |
Definitely a blocker as we should never revert users search engines, even if they're removed from Brave. This is even more problematic with iOS due to not being able to re-add search engines. This is the same behaviour b-c is using and should be the same behaviour on iOS/android as per earlier discussions with @rebron and others when implementing the above spec/work. |
Verified passed when updating from 1.7.3 (19.1.23.19) on Test Flight to 1.8 (19.2.26.22) on Test Flight using iPad 5th Gen. Verified STR for US, France, and Germany regions for both Normal and Private tab search engines. |
Verification passed on when updating from 1.7.3 (19.1.23.19) to 1.8 (19.2.26.22) on Test Flight using iPhone SE. Regions tested: Poland, US, Germany, Russia. |
Verification PASSED on
Went through the above cases at least 10 times on each device using different combination of search engines. |
Description:
Upgrading
1.7.4 (19.02.01.22)
-->1.8 (19.02.20.22)
will always revert the search engine to the regions default (either Google/Qwant) even though the user has already picked another default from the preexisting list.Steps to Reproduce
1.7.4 (19.02.01.22)
from the App Store and open BraveAmazon
and the PB default toYahoo
1.8 (19.02.20.22)
using theipa
file that was providedActual result:
Currently reverting the default search engine to either Google/Qwant every time.
Expected result:
If a user has selected another search engine from the preexisting list, we should honour that choice.
Reproduces how often: [Easily reproduced, Intermittent Issue]
100% reproducible using the above STR.
Brave Version:
Upgrading from 1.7.4 (19.02.01.22)
-->
1.8 (19.02.20.22)`Device details:
Used
iPad Mini 4 running iOS 12.1.4
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: