[GOBBLIN-1948] Use same flowExecutionId across participants #3819

umustafi · 2023-11-02T18:55:07Z

Dear Gobblin maintainers,

Please accept this PR. I understand that it will not be reviewed until I have checked off all the steps below!

JIRA

My PR addresses the following Gobblin JIRA issues and references them in the PR title. For example, "[GOBBLIN-XXX] My Gobblin PR"
- https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/GOBBLIN-1948

Description

Here are some details about my PR, including screenshots (if applicable):
A consistent flowExecutionId is used during lease arbitration between hosts and that id is available to the DagActionStoreChangeMonitor but not used when passing launch events to the Orchestrator for recompilation and eventual execution. The unintended consequence of this is that a different flowExecutionId will be used across each participant when the flow is recompiled before passing to the DagManager. This messes up the job status of the most recent flow execution of each flow as it appears there are N flow execution Ids, 1 for each of the N hosts. Only one will be executed but the other N-1 are stuck in "compiling" job status state.

Tests

My PR adds the following unit tests OR does not need testing for this extremely good reason:
Tests addProperty method added

Commits

My commits all reference JIRA issues in their subject lines, and I have squashed multiple commits if they address the same issue. In addition, my commits follow the guidelines from "How to write a good git commit message":
1. Subject is separated from body by a blank line
2. Subject is limited to 50 characters
3. Subject does not end with a period
4. Subject uses the imperative mood ("add", not "adding")
5. Body wraps at 72 characters
6. Body explains "what" and "why", not "how"

arjun4084346 · 2023-11-02T18:59:48Z

gobblin-runtime/src/main/java/org/apache/gobblin/runtime/api/FlowSpec.java

+  public FlowSpec addProperty(String path, String value) {
+    Properties properties = this.getConfigAsProperties();
+    properties.setProperty(path, value);
+    return new Builder(this.getUri()).withConfigAsProperties(properties).build();


Do you intend to clone a new FlowSpec?

This should create a new FlowSpec with the shared configAsProperties object. I think you did not mean to do that.

also, i think we should add configs to config field also. that is a better source of truth.

Yes I have to clone and create a new FlowSpec because type safe Configs are immutable plus we have made Config a final variable (All variables are final). Rather than change what may be a core idea that FlowSpecs are immutable, I am creating a clone which has all the previous properties and URI plus the new one.

I can also update the Config field, I thought it would get sync'd with the Properties but doesn't look like it. Making a change and updating test too.

My concern here is mostly that it would create a decent amount of object churn, given the size of configs it should lead to an increase of jvm GC given that this would happen once per execution.

That being said it might be an overoptimization to enforce such a rule until you instrument results on a high load, the alternative would be messy, need to add a way for compileSpec() to take in a flow execution ID and enforce using that ID instead of using the provided one in the flow config or from the system time, which would also lead to a bit of an anti-pattern of compiler expecting to use either the flow config's ID (that you provided here) or it's own generated ID.

Yea, I do not prefer cloning too, but config is final here. Not sure if it should be.
Regarding the extra objects, the spec created in line 201 should lose reference by line 204, so we should be good at least in this case.

with the name changed to createFlowSpecWithProperty it becomes more clear that this method is creating a new spec and callers should not hold the reference of the original spec. Maybe we can write it in the methods javadoc @umustafi

codecov-commenter · 2023-11-02T19:16:44Z

Codecov Report

Merging #3819 (b116762) into master (c865b6a) will decrease coverage by 0.15%.
Report is 1 commits behind head on master.
The diff coverage is 40.00%.

@@             Coverage Diff              @@
##             master    #3819      +/-   ##
============================================
- Coverage     47.66%   47.51%   -0.15%     
+ Complexity    11058    11021      -37     
============================================
  Files          2156     2156              
  Lines         85328    85339      +11     
  Branches       9485     9487       +2     
============================================
- Hits          40671    40549     -122     
- Misses        40966    41088     +122     
- Partials       3691     3702      +11

Files	Coverage Δ
.../java/org/apache/gobblin/runtime/api/FlowSpec.java	`43.47% <100.00%> (+4.94%)`	⬆️
...ervice/monitoring/DagActionStoreChangeMonitor.java	`0.00% <0.00%> (ø)`

... and 21 files with indirect coverage changes

📣 Codecov offers a browser extension for seamless coverage viewing on GitHub. Try it in Chrome or Firefox today!

arjun4084346 · 2023-11-03T16:46:21Z

gobblin-runtime/src/main/java/org/apache/gobblin/runtime/api/FlowSpec.java

+   * @param path key for new property
+   * @param value
+   */
+  public FlowSpec addProperty(String path, String value) {


lgtm , one last comment.
lets rename it to createFlowSpecWithProperty and move it to FlowSpec.Utils

arjun4084346

+1 LGTM

* [GOBBLIN-1921] Properly handle reminder events (apache#3790) * Add millisecond level precision to timestamp cols & proper timezone conversion - existing tests pass with minor modifications * Handle reminder events properly * Fix compilation errors & add isReminder flag * Add unit tests * Address review comments * Add newline to address comment * Include reminder/original tag in logging * Clarify timezone issues in comment --------- Co-authored-by: Urmi Mustafi <umustafi@linkedin.com> * [GOBBLIN-1924] Reminder event flag true (apache#3795) * Set reminder event flag to true for reminders * Update unit tests * remove unused variable --------- Co-authored-by: Urmi Mustafi <umustafi@linkedin.com> * [GOBBLIN-1923] Add retention for lease arbiter table (apache#3792) * Add retention for lease arbiter table * Replace blocking thread with scheduled thread pool executor * Make Calendar instance thread-safe * Rename variables, make values more clear * Update timestamp related cols --------- Co-authored-by: Urmi Mustafi <umustafi@linkedin.com> * Change debug statements to info temporarily to debug (apache#3796) Co-authored-by: Urmi Mustafi <umustafi@linkedin.com> * [GOBBLIN-1926] Fix Reminder Event Epsilon Comparison (apache#3797) * Fix Reminder Event Epsilon Comparison * Add TODO comment --------- Co-authored-by: Urmi Mustafi <umustafi@linkedin.com> * [GOBBLIN-1930] Improve Multi-active related logs and metrics (apache#3800) * Improve Multi-active related logs and metrics * Add more metrics and logs around forwarding dag action to DagManager * Improve logs in response to review comments * Replace flow execution id with trigger timestamp from multi-active * Update flow action execution id within lease arbiter * Fix test & make Lease Statuses more lean * Update javadoc --------- Co-authored-by: Urmi Mustafi <umustafi@linkedin.com> * add dataset root in some common type of datasets * [GOBBLIN-1927] Add topic validation support in KafkaSource, and add TopicNameValidator (apache#3793) * * Add generic topic validation support * Add the first validator TopicNameValidator into the validator chain, as a refactor of existing codes * Refine to address comments * Refine --------- Co-authored-by: Tao Qin <tqin@linkedin.com> * [GOBBLIN-1931] Refactor dag action updating method & add clarifying comment (apache#3801) * Refactor dag action updating method & add clarifying comment * Log filtered out duplicate messages * logs and metrics for missing messages from change monitor * Only add gobblin.service prefix for dagActionStoreChangeMonitor --------- Co-authored-by: Urmi Mustafi <umustafi@linkedin.com> * [GOBBLIN-1934] Monitor High Level Consumer queue size (apache#3805) * Emit metrics to monitor high level consumer queue size * Empty commit to trigger tests * Use BlockingQueue.size() func instead of atomic integer array * Remove unused import & add DagActionChangeMonitor prefix to metric * Refactor to avoid repeating code * Make protected variables private where possible * Fix white space --------- Co-authored-by: Urmi Mustafi <umustafi@linkedin.com> * [GOBBLIN-1935] Skip null dag action types unable to be processed (apache#3807) * Skip over null dag actions from malformed messages * Add new metric for skipped messages --------- Co-authored-by: Urmi Mustafi <umustafi@linkedin.com> * [GOBBLIN-1922]Add function in Kafka Source to recompute workUnits for filtered partitions (apache#3798) * add function in Kafka Source to recompute workUnits for filtered partitions * address comments * set default min container value to 1 * add condition when create empty wu * update the condition * Expose functions to fetch record partitionColumn value (apache#3810) * [GOBBLIN-1938] preserve x bit in manifest file based copy (apache#3804) * preserve x bit in manifest file based copy * fix project structure preventing running unit tests from intellij * fix unit test * [GOBBLIN-1919] Simplify a few elements of MR-related job exec before reusing code in Temporal-based execution (apache#3784) * Simplify a few elements of MR-related job exec before reusing code in Temporal-based execution * Add JSON-ification to several foundational config-state representations, plus encapsulated convience method `JobState.getJobIdFromProps` * Update javadoc comments * Encapsulate check for whether a path has the extension of a multi-work-unit * [GOBBLIN-1939] Bump AWS version to use a compatible version of Jackson with Gobblin (apache#3809) * Bump AWS version to use a compatible version of jackson with Gobblin * use shared aws version * [GOBBLIN-1937] Quantify Missed Work Completed by Reminders (apache#3808) * Quantify Missed Work Completed by Reminders Also fix bug to filter out heartbeat events before extracting field * Refactor changeMonitorUtils & add delimiter to metrics prefix * Re-order params to group similar ones --------- Co-authored-by: Urmi Mustafi <umustafi@linkedin.com> * GOBBLIN-1933]Change the logic in completeness verifier to support multi reference tier (apache#3806) * address comments * use connectionmanager when httpclient is not cloesable * [GOBBLIN-1933] Change the logic in completeness verifier to support multi reference tier * add uite test * fix typo * change the javadoc * change the javadoc --------- Co-authored-by: Zihan Li <zihli@zihli-mn2.linkedin.biz> * [GOBBLIN-1943] Use AWS version 1.12.261 to fix a security vulnerability in the previous version (apache#3813) * [GOBBLIN-1941] Develop Temporal abstractions, including `Workload` for workflows of unbounded size through sub-workflow nesting (apache#3811) * Define `Workload` abstraction for Temporal workflows of unbounded size through sub-workflow nesting * Adjust Gobblin-Temporal configurability for consistency and abstraction * Define `WorkerConfig`, to pass the `TemporalWorker`'s configuration to the workflows and activities it hosts * Improve javadoc * Javadoc fixup * Minor changes * Update per review suggestions * Insert pause, to spread the load on the temporal server, before launch of each child workflow that may have direct leaves of its own * Appease findbugs by having `SeqSliceBackedWorkSpan::next` throw `NoSuchElementException` * Add comment * [GOBBLIN-1944] Add gobblin-temporal load generator for a single subsuming super-workflow with a configurable number of activities nested beneath (apache#3815) * Add gobblin-temporal load generator for a single subsuming super-workflow with a configurable number of activities nested beneath * Update per findbugs advice * Improve processing of int props * [GOBBLIN-1945] Implement Distributed Data Movement (DDM) Gobblin-on-Temporal `WorkUnit` evaluation (apache#3816) * Implement Distributed Data Movement (DDM) Gobblin-on-Temporal `WorkUnit` evaluation * Adjust work unit processing tuning for start-to-close timeout and nested execution branching * Rework `ProcessWorkUnitImpl` and fix `FileSystem` misuse; plus convenience abstractions to load `FileSystem`, `JobState`, and `StateStore<TaskState>` * Fix `FileSystem` resource lifecycle, uniquely name each workflow, and drastically reduce worker concurrent task execution * Heed findbugs advice * prep before commit * Improve processing of required props * Update comment in response to PR feedback * [GOBBLIN-1942] Create MySQL util class for re-usable methods and setup MysqlDagActio… (apache#3812) * Create MySQL util class for re-usable methods and setup MysqlDagActionStore retention * Add a java doc * Address review comments * Close scheduled executors on shutdown & clarify naming and comments * Remove extra period making config key invalid * implement Closeable * Use try with resources --------- Co-authored-by: Urmi Mustafi <umustafi@linkedin.com> * [Hotfix][GOBBLIN-1949] add option to detect malformed orc during commit (apache#3818) * add option to detect malformed ORC during commit phase * better logging * address comment * catch more generic exception * validate ORC file after close * move validate in between close and commit * syntax * whitespace * update log * [GOBBLIN-1948] Use same flowExecutionId across participants (apache#3819) * Use same flowExecutionId across participants * Set config field as well in new FlowSpec * Use gobblin util to create config * Rename function and move to util --------- Co-authored-by: Urmi Mustafi <umustafi@linkedin.com> * Allow extension of functions in GobblinMCEPublisher and customization of fileList file metrics are calculated for (apache#3820) * [GOBBLIN-1951] Emit GTE when deleting corrupted ORC files (apache#3821) * [GOBBLIN-1951] Emit GTE when deleting corrupted ORC files This commit adds ORC file validation during the commit phase and deletes corrupted files. It also includes a test for ORC file validation. * Linter fixes * Add framework and unit tests for DagActionStoreChangeMonitor (apache#3817) * Add framework and unit tests for DagActionStoreChangeMonitor * Add more test cases and validation * Add header for new file * Move FlowSpec static function to Utils class * Remove unused import * Fix compile error * Fix unit tests --------- Co-authored-by: Urmi Mustafi <umustafi@linkedin.com> * [GOBBLIN-1952] Make jobname shortening in GaaS more aggressive (apache#3822) * Make jobname shortening in GaaS more aggressive * Change long name prefix to flowgroup * Make KafkaTopicGroupingWorkUnitPacker pack with desired num of container (apache#3814) * Make KafkaTopicGroupingWorkUnitPacker pack with desired num of container * update comment * [GOBBLIN-1953] Add an exception message to orc writer validation GTE (apache#3826) * Fix FlowSpec Updating Function (apache#3823) * Fix FlowSpec Updating Function * makes Config object with FlowSpec mutable * adds unit test to ensure flow compiles after updating FlowSpec * ensure DagManager resilient to exceptions on leadership change * Only update Properties obj not Config to avoid GC overhead * Address findbugs error * Avoid updating or creating new FlowSpec objects by passing flowExecutionId directly to metadata * Remove changes that are not needed anymore * Add TODO to handle failed DagManager leadership change * Overload function and add more documentation --------- Co-authored-by: Urmi Mustafi <umustafi@linkedin.com> * Emit metric to tune LeaseArbiter Linger metric (apache#3824) * Monitor number of failed persisting leases to tune linger * Increase default linger and epsilon values * Add metric for lease persisting success * Rename metrics --------- Co-authored-by: Urmi Mustafi <umustafi@linkedin.com> * [GOBBLIN-1956]Make Kafka streaming pipeline be able to config the max poll records during runtime (apache#3827) * address comments * use connectionmanager when httpclient is not cloesable * add uite test * fix typo * [GOBBLIN-1956] Make Kafka streaming pipeline be able to config the max poll records during runtime * small refractor --------- Co-authored-by: Zihan Li <zihli@zihli-mn2.linkedin.biz> * Add semantics for failure on partial success (apache#3831) * Consistly handle Rest.li /flowexecutions KILL and RESUME actions (apache#3830) * [GOBBLIN-1957] GobblinOrcwriter improvements for large records (apache#3828) * WIP * Optimization to limit batchsize based on large record sizes * Address review * Use DB-qualified table ID as `IcebergTable` dataset descriptor (apache#3834) * [GOBBLIN-1961] Allow `IcebergDatasetFinder` to use separate names for source vs. destination-side DB and table (apache#3835) * Allow `IcebergDatasetFinder` to use separate names for source vs. destination-side DB and table * Adjust Mockito.verify to pass test * Prevent NPE in `FlowCompilationValidationHelper.validateAndHandleConcurrentExecution` (apache#3836) * Prevent NPE in `FlowCompilationValidationHelper.validateAndHandleConcurrentExecution` * improved `MultiHopFlowCompiler` javadoc * Delete Launch Action Events After Processing (apache#3837) * Delete launch action event after persisting * Fix default value for flowExecutionId retrieval from metadata map * Address review comments and add unit test * Code clean up --------- Co-authored-by: Urmi Mustafi <umustafi@linkedin.com> * [GOBBLIN-1960] Emit audit count after commit in IcebergMetadataWriter (apache#3833) * Emit audit count after commit in IcebergMetadataWriter * Unit tests by extracting to a post commit * Emit audit count first * find bugs complaint * [GOBBLIN-1967] Add external data node for generic ingress/egress on GaaS (apache#3838) * Add external data node for generic ingress/egress on GaaS * Address reviews and cleanup * Use URI representation for external dataset descriptor node * Fix error message in containing check * Address review * [GOBBLIN-1971] Allow `IcebergCatalog` to specify the `DatasetDescriptor` name for the `IcebergTable`s it creates (apache#3842) * Allow `IcebergCatalog` to specify the `DatasetDescriptor` name for the `IcebergTable`s it creates * small method javadoc * [GOBBLIN-1970] Consolidate processing dag actions to one code path (apache#3841) * Consolidate processing dag actions to one code path * Delete dag action in failure cases too * Distinguish metrics for startup * Refactor to avoid duplicated code and create static metrics proxy class * Remove DagManager checks that don't apply on startup * Add test to check kill/resume dag action removal after processing * Remove unused import * Initialize metrics proxy with Null Pattern --------- Co-authored-by: Urmi Mustafi <umustafi@linkedin.com> * [GOBBLIN-1972] Fix `CopyDataPublisher` to avoid committing post-publish WUs before they've actually run (apache#3844) * Fix `CopyDataPublisher` to avoid committing post-publish WUs before they've actually run * fixup findbugsMain * [GOBBLIN-1975] Keep job.name configuration immutable if specified on GaaS (apache#3847) * Revert "[GOBBLIN-1952] Make jobname shortening in GaaS more aggressive (apache#3822)" This reverts commit 5619a0a. * use configuration to keep specified jobname if enabled * Cleanup * [GOBBLIN-1974] Ensure Adhoc Flows can be Executed in Multi-active Scheduler state (apache#3846) * Ensure Adhoc Flows can be Executed in Multi-active Scheduler state * Only delete spec for adhoc flows & always after orchestration * Delete adhoc flows when dagManager is not present as well * Fix flaky test for scheduler * Add clarifying comment about failure recovery * Re-ordered private method * Move private methods again * Enforce sequential ordering of unit tests to make more reliable --------- Co-authored-by: Urmi Mustafi <umustafi@linkedin.com> * [GOBBLIN-1973] Change Manifest distcp logic to compare permissions of source and dest files even when source is older (apache#3845) * change should copy logic * Add tests, address review * Fix checkstyle * Remove unused imports * [GOBBLIN-1976] Allow an `IcebergCatalog` to override the `DatasetDescriptor` platform name for the `IcebergTable`s it creates (apache#3848) * Allow an `IcebergCatalog` to override the `DatasetDescriptor` platform for the `IcebergTable`s it creates * fixup javadoc * Log when `PasswordManager` fails to load any master password (apache#3849) * [GOBBLIN-1968] Temporal commit step integration (apache#3829) Add commit step to Gobblin temporal workflow for job publish * Add codeql analysis * Make gradle specific * Add codeql as part of build script * Initialize codeql * Use separate workflow for codeql instead with custom build function as autobuild seems to not work * Add jdk jar for global dependencies script --------- Co-authored-by: umustafi <umust77@gmail.com> Co-authored-by: Urmi Mustafi <umustafi@linkedin.com> Co-authored-by: Arjun <abora@linkedin.com> Co-authored-by: Tao Qin <35046097+wsarecv@users.noreply.github.com> Co-authored-by: Tao Qin <tqin@linkedin.com> Co-authored-by: Hanghang Nate Liu <nate.hanghang.liu@gmail.com> Co-authored-by: Andy Jiang <andy.jiang99@outlook.com> Co-authored-by: Kip Kohn <ckohn@linkedin.com> Co-authored-by: Zihan Li <zihli@linkedin.com> Co-authored-by: Zihan Li <zihli@zihli-mn2.linkedin.biz> Co-authored-by: Matthew Ho <mho@linkedin.com>

Use same flowExecutionId across participants

0327e06

arjun4084346 reviewed Nov 2, 2023

View reviewed changes

Urmi Mustafi added 2 commits November 2, 2023 14:06

Set config field as well in new FlowSpec

e553f9d

Use gobblin util to create config

be24042

arjun4084346 reviewed Nov 3, 2023

View reviewed changes

Rename function and move to util

b116762

arjun4084346 approved these changes Nov 3, 2023

View reviewed changes

arjun4084346 merged commit 6b6b70c into apache:master Nov 3, 2023
6 checks passed

Provide feedback

Saved searches

Use saved searches to filter your results more quickly

[GOBBLIN-1948] Use same flowExecutionId across participants #3819

[GOBBLIN-1948] Use same flowExecutionId across participants #3819

umustafi commented Nov 2, 2023

arjun4084346 Nov 2, 2023

arjun4084346 Nov 2, 2023

arjun4084346 Nov 2, 2023

umustafi Nov 2, 2023

umustafi Nov 2, 2023

Will-Lo Nov 3, 2023

arjun4084346 Nov 3, 2023 •

edited

Loading

arjun4084346 Nov 3, 2023

codecov-commenter commented Nov 2, 2023 •

edited

Loading

arjun4084346 Nov 3, 2023

umustafi Nov 3, 2023

arjun4084346 left a comment

[GOBBLIN-1948] Use same flowExecutionId across participants #3819

[GOBBLIN-1948] Use same flowExecutionId across participants #3819

Conversation

umustafi commented Nov 2, 2023

JIRA

Description

Tests

Commits

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

arjun4084346 Nov 3, 2023 • edited Loading

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

codecov-commenter commented Nov 2, 2023 • edited Loading

Codecov Report

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

arjun4084346 left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

arjun4084346 Nov 3, 2023 •

edited

Loading

codecov-commenter commented Nov 2, 2023 •

edited

Loading