You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
Are you sure the computation of pairwise mutual information in the hashing example is correct? I've been working through the maths (and reverse-engineering what you compute) and I'm not entirely convinced that the value you compute is correct.
You seem to be evaluating p(Y_a, Y_b | X) * lg (p(Y_a, Y_b | X) / p(Y_a, Y_b))
Whereas I was expecting the correct term to be I(Y_a ; Y_b) = H(Y_a) - H(Y_a | Y_b) =p(Y_a) * lg(p(Y_a)) - p(Y_a, Y_b) * lg (p(Y_a, Y_b) / p(Y_b))
I'm not certain yet though. Do you have any notes on how you derived the current form?
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:
Hey,
Are you sure the computation of pairwise mutual information in the hashing example is correct? I've been working through the maths (and reverse-engineering what you compute) and I'm not entirely convinced that the value you compute is correct.
You seem to be evaluating p(Y_a, Y_b | X) * lg (p(Y_a, Y_b | X) / p(Y_a, Y_b))
Whereas I was expecting the correct term to be I(Y_a ; Y_b) = H(Y_a) - H(Y_a | Y_b) =p(Y_a) * lg(p(Y_a)) - p(Y_a, Y_b) * lg (p(Y_a, Y_b) / p(Y_b))
I'm not certain yet though. Do you have any notes on how you derived the current form?
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: