Feedback: "Navigate to an expanded disclosure button from a link in the associated dropdown" (Disclosure Navigation Menu Example, Test 11, V24.07.31)

[tactics2]

Description of Behavior

Test Setup

• Test File: test-53-navToExpandedDisclosureButtonFromLinkAssociatedDropdown-voiceover_macos.collected.html
• AT: VoiceOver for macOS (Version 14.5)
• Browser: Safari (Version 17)

Review Conflicts for "Navigate to an expanded disclosure button from a link in the associated dropdown"

1. Assertion Results for "Control+Option+Left Arrow, then Control+Option+Left Arrow" Command and "List boundary is conveyed" Assertion

   • Tester tactics2 recorded output "- list, 4 items, level 2 - about, expanded button" and marked assertion as failing.
   • Tester IsaDC recorded output " list 4 items level 2 About expanded button You are currently on a button. To click this button, press Control-Option-Space." and marked assertion as passing.

2. Unexpected Behaviors for "Shift+Tab" Command

   • Tester tactics2 recorded output "about, expanded button, list, 3 items" and noted "Other (Details: incorrectly announces that the list has 3 items instead of 4, Impact: MODERATE)".
   • Tester IsaDC recorded output " About expanded button list 3 items" and noted no unexpected behavior.

I marked it as failing because there is no definition of "list boundary is conveyed" in the test parameters. It is announced as a list, but what is a "boundary"?.

It also fails because it identifies the incorrect number of list items, but that is not in the test criteria, only that it announces it as a list. So technically it passes, even though it outputs incorrect information. IsaDC recorded the same results, but didn't mark it as an unexpected behavior in the comments.