[FEAT] Aperture photometry plugin could "live update" the displayed layer

[eteq]

Jdaviz component

Imviz

What is the problem this feature will solve?

When using the aperture photometry plugin, one can get into a confusing state by doing the following:

1. Load two datasets A and B - B will be what's displayed be default
2. In the apphot plugin, select dataset A
3. Now draw a region based on what you see in that moment
4. Hit "calculate".

Confusingly, the results are for aperture photometry on dataset A even though B is the one you can see in imviz at that moment.

Describe the desired outcome

Many solutions (including none are possible)... But I think my favored solutions are this

Non-batch mode

When the user selects a single layer that's not the visible one, either:

1. Show a big red box that says "YOU ARENT LOOKING AT THE SAME THING YOUR PHOTOMETERING! THIS MIGHT BE CONFUSING, SILLY USER!"
2. Automatically update the viewer to show only the layer that has been selected
3. have 2 happen only with a checkbox selected (which would be on by default)

I think 3 is the best, but 2 or 1 are OK fallbacks.

Batch mode

1. Show the big red box if none of the selected layers are the currently visible one
2. Select all the layers and have it start blinking through them
3. 2 with a checkbox checked, 1 if it's not (off by default)

Same as above, I like them in order of 3,2,1

Additional context

🐱

[pllim]

I think this is a general problem across all plugins because of:

• Imviz: Selected data in Layers menu should follow display #743

[kecnry]

"Currently visible" isn't the easiest thing to determine in general because of possible layer (semi-)transparencies, but I like the idea of showing a message in cases like this (plugins that take data as input) when the selected entry isn't the top layer in any viewer.

[camipacifici]

I like this too!