diff --git a/plans/convert.pp b/plans/convert.pp
index 2642ccd7c..41c70883d 100644
--- a/plans/convert.pp
+++ b/plans/convert.pp
@@ -306,9 +306,13 @@
     # Restart cluster compiler services that are likely not restarted by our
     # final Puppet run to increase chance everything is functional upon plan
     # completion
-    run_command('systemctl restart pe-puppetserver.service pe-puppetdb.service',
+    run_command('systemctl restart pe-puppetserver.service',
     $all_targets - $primary_target - $primary_postgresql_target - $replica_postgresql_target)
 
+    # PuppetDB is only found on modern compilers, not legacy ones
+    run_command('systemctl restart pe-puppetdb.service',
+    $all_targets - $primary_target - $primary_postgresql_target - $replica_postgresql_target - $legacy_compiler_targets)
+
     # Run puppet on all targets again to ensure everything is fully up-to-date
     run_task('peadm::puppet_runonce', $all_targets)
   }