HCOLL is causing XRC problems in v2.x

[artpol84]

This problem was originally treated as an btl/openib issue: #3890.
However more detailed investigation indicating that this is an effect of coll/hcoll component: #4082

Without hcoll it runs ok:

$ bash -x ./run.sh                                                                                                                                                      
+ ./mpirun -np 8 -bind-to none -mca orte_tmpdir_base /tmp/tmp.8mj45mghXh -mca btl_openib_if_include mlx5_0:1 -x MXM_RDMA_PORTS=mlx5_0:1 -x UCX_NET_DEVICES=mlx5_0:1 -x UCX_TLS=rc,cm -mca pml ob1 -mca btl self,openib -mca coll '^hcoll' -mca btl_openib_receive_queues X,4096,1024:X,12288,512:X,65536,512 taskset -c 6,7 /hpc/home/USERS/artemp/scrap/OMPI/ompi/examples/hello_c
Hello, world, I am 2 of 8, (Open MPI v2.1.2rc1, package: Open MPI artemp@jenkins03 Distribution, ident: 2.1.2rc1, repo rev: v2.1.1-154-g459e5ae, Unreleased developer copy, 143)
Hello, world, I am 7 of 8, (Open MPI v2.1.2rc1, package: Open MPI artemp@jenkins03 Distribution, ident: 2.1.2rc1, repo rev: v2.1.1-154-g459e5ae, Unreleased developer copy, 143)
Hello, world, I am 4 of 8, (Open MPI v2.1.2rc1, package: Open MPI artemp@jenkins03 Distribution, ident: 2.1.2rc1, repo rev: v2.1.1-154-g459e5ae, Unreleased developer copy, 143)
Hello, world, I am 6 of 8, (Open MPI v2.1.2rc1, package: Open MPI artemp@jenkins03 Distribution, ident: 2.1.2rc1, repo rev: v2.1.1-154-g459e5ae, Unreleased developer copy, 143)
Hello, world, I am 3 of 8, (Open MPI v2.1.2rc1, package: Open MPI artemp@jenkins03 Distribution, ident: 2.1.2rc1, repo rev: v2.1.1-154-g459e5ae, Unreleased developer copy, 143)
Hello, world, I am 5 of 8, (Open MPI v2.1.2rc1, package: Open MPI artemp@jenkins03 Distribution, ident: 2.1.2rc1, repo rev: v2.1.1-154-g459e5ae, Unreleased developer copy, 143)
Hello, world, I am 0 of 8, (Open MPI v2.1.2rc1, package: Open MPI artemp@jenkins03 Distribution, ident: 2.1.2rc1, repo rev: v2.1.1-154-g459e5ae, Unreleased developer copy, 143)
Hello, world, I am 1 of 8, (Open MPI v2.1.2rc1, package: Open MPI artemp@jenkins03 Distribution, ident: 2.1.2rc1, repo rev: v2.1.1-154-g459e5ae, Unreleased developer copy, 143)
+ exit 0

While enabling hcoll introduces the problem:

$ bash -x ./run.sh                                                                                                                                                      
+ ./mpirun -np 8 -bind-to none -mca orte_tmpdir_base /tmp/tmp.8mj45mghXh -mca btl_openib_if_include mlx5_0:1 -x MXM_RDMA_PORTS=mlx5_0:1 -x UCX_NET_DEVICES=mlx5_0:1 -x UCX_TLS=rc,cm -mca pml ob1 -mca btl self,openib -mca btl_openib_receive_queues X,4096,1024:X,12288,512:X,65536,512 taskset -c 6,7 /hpc/home/USERS/artemp/scrap/OMPI/ompi/examples/hello_c
[1502826187.186194] [jenkins03:21885:0]         sys.c:744  MXM  WARN  Conflicting CPU frequencies detected, using: 3499.45
[1502826187.188457] [jenkins03:21888:0]         sys.c:744  MXM  WARN  Conflicting CPU frequencies detected, using: 3499.45
[1502826187.192728] [jenkins03:21886:0]         sys.c:744  MXM  WARN  Conflicting CPU frequencies detected, using: 3499.45
[1502826187.194526] [jenkins03:21884:0]         sys.c:744  MXM  WARN  Conflicting CPU frequencies detected, using: 3499.45
[1502826187.200721] [jenkins03:21887:0]         sys.c:744  MXM  WARN  Conflicting CPU frequencies detected, using: 3499.45
[1502826187.206316] [jenkins03:21890:0]         sys.c:744  MXM  WARN  Conflicting CPU frequencies detected, using: 3499.45
[1502826187.209630] [jenkins03:21889:0]         sys.c:744  MXM  WARN  Conflicting CPU frequencies detected, using: 3499.45
[1502826187.215512] [jenkins03:21891:0]         sys.c:744  MXM  WARN  Conflicting CPU frequencies detected, using: 3499.45
+ echo 255
255

[artpol84]

@hjelmn @hppritcha
One side effect of this issue that I've noticed is that OMPI fails silently in this case leaving no chance to regular user to understand that it even fails. Even we were thinking that all is good at the very beginning because the output was clean.

[artpol84]

@jladd-mlnx @vspetrov @bureddy

[jsquyres]

Per #4082 (comment), @vspetrov is claiming the problem is definitely in the openib BTL.

Is there an XRC problem in both hcoll and openib?

[artpol84]

@jsquyres I think that @vspetrov demonstrated that hcoll is just triggering the problem in openib by mimic it's activity with Allreduce and disabling hcoll.
So as I understand it - it is not an hcoll bug, but hcoll creates allowable conditions where XRC is failing.

[jsquyres]

So do you want to close all those "Revert..." PRs?

[artpol84]

Yes. I guess that I answered the question from this weeks telecon: only v2.x demonstrates this kind of problems with openib, all other branches are OK (according to our Jenkins at least).

[artpol84]

I think we can close this issue as well