Peer Review #2

[sophiabrothers1]

Opening statement summary
You have a lot to complete with the rest of your paper, but the parts you have done are strong

Strong positive points

• Your graphs are very clear and I understand what you are trying to say
• Your introduction is pretty fleshed out and well articulated
• Limitations for data are valid and make sense and are important to include so its good to see
• Sketches look good
• Data parts of the repository look good
• LLM is documented

Critical improvements needed

• Finish the paper
• Update your readme

Suggestions for improvement:

• Add figure captions
• Clean up the graphs (overlapping text)

Please consider adding/changing/removing:

• Add your GitHub repo to the paper
• I would include a table using knitr

Evaluation:
The repository is very well done for the parts you have completed, and I love your introduction. Finish your paper and clean up the readme, etc and you should be in very good shape

Estimated mark: 35/100

Reason: the estimated mark is low because there is a lot left to be completed. This mark would go up dramatically with the completion of your paper