Master tracking issue for removing BinaryFormatter usage from dotnet libs

[GrabYourPitchforks]

This issue tracks the tagging and removal of BinaryFormatter-related code paths from various dotnet org repos. See dotnet/designs#141 for more information.

dotnet/runtime

• Obsolete SerializationFormat.Binary in DataTable/DataSet and put it behind an appcontext switch #39289 - usage in DataSet
• Remove BinaryFormatter usage from ResourceReader #39290 - usage in ResourceReader
• Remove BinaryFormatter usage from System.Resources.Extensions #39292 - usage in System.Resources.Extensions
• Remove BinaryFormatter usage from System.ComponentModel.TypeConverter #39293 - usage in System.ComponentModel.TypeConverter (Prohibit BF unless the app opts in #48527)
• Remove BinaryFormatter usage from SettingsPropertyValue #39295 - usage in System.Configuration.ConfigurationManager (BinaryFormatter deprecation for System.Configuration.ConfigurationManager #50531)
• Consider allowing Exception instances to be serialized without requiring BinaryFormatter #43482 - Exception serialization without BinaryFormatter

Documentation of Breaking Changes

As part of the definition of done for each of these items, we must identify possibilities where changing serialization formats could be a breaking change for customers. For instance, if the serialized output could have been persisted to disk, we will likely need to document where the deserialization of persisted data could be affected.

[ghost]

Tagging subscribers to this area: @dotnet/area-system-security, @vcsjones
See info in area-owners.md if you want to be subscribed.

Issue Details

---

This issue tracks the tagging and removal of BinaryFormatter-related code paths from various dotnet org repos. See dotnet/designs#141 for more information.

dotnet/runtime

• Obsolete SerializationFormat.Binary in DataTable/DataSet and put it behind an appcontext switch #39289 - usage in DataSet
• Remove BinaryFormatter usage from ResourceReader #39290 - usage in ResourceReader
• Remove BinaryFormatter usage from System.Resources.Extensions #39292 - usage in System.Resources.Extensions
• Remove BinaryFormatter usage from System.ComponentModel.TypeConverter #39293 - usage in System.ComponentModel.TypeConverter (Prohibit BF unless the app opts in #48527)
• Remove BinaryFormatter usage from SettingsPropertyValue #39295 - usage in System.Configuration.ConfigurationManager (BinaryFormatter deprecation for System.Configuration.ConfigurationManager #50531)
• Consider allowing Exception instances to be serialized without requiring BinaryFormatter #43482 - Exception serialization without BinaryFormatter

Documentation of Breaking Changes

As part of the definition of done for each of these items, we must identify possibilities where changing serialization formats could be a breaking change for customers. For instance, if the serialized output could have been persisted to disk, we will likely need to document where the deserialization of persisted data could be affected.

Author:	GrabYourPitchforks
Assignees:	jeffhandley, GrabYourPitchforks
Labels:	area-System.Runtime, area-System.Security, User Story, Priority:2, Cost:L, Team:Libraries
Milestone:	7.0.0

[adamsitnik]

@jeffhandley should we close this issue and move the remaining work to a new one? Or just move it to 9.0?

[jeffhandley]

Let's just move it to 9.0.0. Done.