You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
GSmartControl supports the following RAID controllers:
[...]
Note: Smartmontools supports even more RAID Controllers. The drives behind such controllers can be manually entered in GSmartControl using Add Device… functionality or --add-device command-line option.
I do not know smartmontools well and am far from being sure of what it supports, but if my understanding is correct, I would suggested rephrasing to something like:
GSmartControl supports ATA drives (both PATA and SATA) and NVMe drives when they are directly attached. For drives behind bridges or RAID controllers, see the following section.
GSmartControl supports the following RAID controllers:
[...]
Note: Smartmontools supports even more RAID Controllers. The drives behind such controllers can be manually entered in GSmartControl using Add Device… functionality or --add-device command-line option.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:
Thanks @ashaduri
I wrote this ticket thinking that my own knowledge about hardware has vastly diminished in the last 15 years, and I imagine the text could be intimidating for new generations.
Perhaps it clarifies to specify that SCSI drives are not supported. Also, the new text lists ATA drives, but not which. Perhaps the first 2 items in the list can be numbered and #1 relabelled to "All ATA drives―either serial (SATA) or parallel (PATA)―which support SMART", if that is accurate. Then the third element can read "#1 and #2 behind some USB bridges […]".
I left the rest as is. The page already lists SATA and PATA drives. As for the SMART support, any non-buggy hdd/ssd has SMART support, unless it's connected via USB, and USB bridges are listed separately.
I also do not want to use the term "directly attached" - it is very vague and may be even more confusing.
Thanks @ashaduri
Yes, the page already lists SATA and PATA drives, but not which. English can be very vague. For example, I can say that my flashlight contains batteries, but it does not mean that it contains all the batteries in the world. In its current state, the page effectively only claims that some ATA drives are supported.
I agree that "directly attached" is vague. However, I think not indicating that attachment matters is misleading.
The Supported Hardware page is very helpful, but I suspect it can be confusing for people with limited experience.
It currently reads:
I do not know smartmontools well and am far from being sure of what it supports, but if my understanding is correct, I would suggested rephrasing to something like:
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: