source_id registration AWI-ESM-1-REcoM

[durack1]

Placeholder issue awaiting publication of AWI-ESM-1-REcoM data on https://esgf-data.dkrz.de/search/cmip6-dkrz/ - Toggling the "Registered" status to "Published" will occur at that point and close out this issue

@chrisdane ping

Ref #1216 #1215

[durack1]

Awaiting publication of https://aims2.llnl.gov/search?project=CMIP6&activeFacets={"source_id":"AWI-ESM-1-REcoM"}

[chrisdane]

Hi Paul, we published data (https://aims2.llnl.gov/search/cmip6/?mip_era=CMIP6&institution_id=AWI&source_id=AWI-ESM-1-REcoM, more to come though).

Please see PR #1233.

Thanks a lot and cheers,
Chris

[durack1]

Add CDRMIP to activity_participation field as per https://github.com/WCRP-CMIP/CMIP6_CVs/pull/1233/files - and toggle status to "Published".

@chrisdane is the earliest published date 2024-07-04? This is what I have identified in https://aims2.llnl.gov/search?project=CMIP6&activeFacets=%7B%22source_id%22:%22AWI-ESM-1-REcoM%22%7D, however you have used a very old ESGF version stamp "v20230314" which isn't ideal

[durack1]

@chrisdane while we're cleaning things up AWI-ESM-2-1-LR has never had any data published against it, so I suggest we deregister, at the same time, ok?

[durack1]

@chrisdane I am unable to access the index of data published on the DKRZ node, it seems https://esgf-metagrid.cloud.dkrz.de/search/cmip6-dkrz/ is not returning any datasets, and the shared index locally (https://aims2.llnl.gov/search/cmip6/?mip_era=CMIP6&institution_id=AWI&source_id=AWI-ESM-1-REcoM) is also not returning results, so I will await your feedback before merging the changes - particularly I want to know the first date that AWI-ESM-1-REcoM data was made available on ESGF, if 2024-07-04 is not right.

And the separate question about AWI-ESM-2-1-LR

[chrisdane]

Hi Paul

For me the data appears on both pages, aims2.llnl.gov and esgf-metagrid.cloud.dkrz.de (searching for 'awi-esm-1-recom'). Maybe it took some time until everything was settled on the servers?

The version stamp v20230314 was used by helping people from our local ESGF node (DKRZ). It is correct that the data was added rather recently, i.e. I think 2024-07-04 is correct. Is that a problem? Apparently it was not a problem for the DKRZ people who in the end decide if data can be uploaded or not. Changing this would require extra work. Thanks for advice.

I cannot say anything about AWI-ESM-2-1-LR, sorry.

Thanks for your help,
Chris

[durack1]

It appears 2024-07-04 is the first publication date for AWI-ESM-1-REcoM - see here (blocked IP ranges).

@chrisdane just as an FYI, the version stamp (v20230314 in the published data) is meant to represent the timestamp of when the data was first written, and hopefully soon thereafter published. As it's well over a year ago, it might confuse some users that this data was just published (20240704), yet has a "version" from 16 months ago. It'd be great to flag this and correct it for any future data preparation.

@chrisdane I can process the AWI-ESM-1-REcoM update. For the AWI-ESM-2-1-LR as this has remained open without comments for a while, so I'll deregister this to close out the stale dialogue. If we need to register this again at some point in the future, the details can easily be retrieved and updated.

Pinging @christian-stepanek to close out the AWI-ESM-2-1-LR discussion

[durack1]

@chrisdane @christian-stepanek those changes (including the ocean/seaIce native_nominal_resolution tweak) are now in CMIP6_source_id.html. Please take a peek and let me know if there are any remaining issues to resolve