[.data.table accept both by and keyby non-missing

[jangorecki]

I would like do conditional sort while making aggregation, I think [.data.table could be less restricted and check only if one of by and keyby is not null.

library(data.table)
dt <- data.table(a = 1:10, b = 1:5)
do_sort <- FALSE
dt[,j = .(a=sum(a)),
   by = if(!do_sort) b else NULL,
   keyby = if(do_sort) b else NULL]
# Error in `[.data.table`(dt, , j = .(a = sum(a)), by = if (!do_sort) b else NULL,  : 
#   Provide either 'by' or 'keyby' but not both

[rsaporta]

why not put the conditional outside of the data.table call? In the given example, there is not much harm, but it might open up to other errors requiring many more checks.

[jangorecki]

Then it would be difficult to use chaining which is not exposed in that example.

[jangorecki]

@rsaporta see line #L409 - by is already cloned from keyby, so it looks like a matter of handling keyby only.
At the first glance setting if(missing(keyby)) keyby <- NULL and then change all following missing(keyby) to is.null(keyby) would solve that issue.

hmm, looks like it can be done even easier just by keyby <- substitute(): SO comment.

I may prepare PR if there is a chance for that to be accepted.

[jangorecki]

example code which suffers from lack of that feature is my dev version of split.data.table #1389

...
if (!missing(keyby)) {
    if (!missing(by)) stop("you must provide 'by' or 'keyby', not both")
    do.key = TRUE
    by = keyby
} else if (!missing(by)) {
    do.key = FALSE
}
tmp = if (do.key) {
    x[, list(.ll.tech.split=list(.SD)), keyby=by, .SDcols=if(drop) setdiff(names(x), by) else names(x)]
} else x[, list(.ll.tech.split=list(.SD)), by=by, .SDcols=if(drop) setdiff(names(x), by) else names(x)]
...

[jangorecki]

Alternatively keyby argument in [.data.table could accept logical scalar - a flag if key should be set on groups provided in by argument. Then grouping columns can be controlled with by and sorting results with keyby.

[jangorecki]

closing as duplicate of newly created #4307 which is well defining requested behaviour