xFirewall doesn't correctly handle Group property #191
Labels
stale
The issue or pull request was marked as stale because there hasn't been activity from the community.
Comments
|
Hello @mjenne - could you please post an example config and the resulting errors that you are seeing? This will help us track this down. |
PlagueHO
added
help wanted
|
Hi @mjenne - is it possible you're seeing something similar to what this issue describes? |
|
Got the same Problem here - Windows Server 2016 Standard RTM + CU2 Don't got a complete Error Message because i'm calling it trough "Ansible" and over WinRM :-) Passed Back Exception Message in JSON: AmbiguousParameterSet,Set-NetFirewallRule "Exception": {
"Data": {},
"ErrorData": {
"CimClass": {
"CimClassMethods": [],
"CimClassProperties": [
{
"CimType": 6,
"Flags": "None",
"Name": "CIMStatusCode",
"Qualifiers": [],
"ReferenceClassName": null,
"Value": 0
},
{
"CimType": 14,
"Flags": "None",
"Name": "CIMStatusCodeDescription",
"Qualifiers": [],
"ReferenceClassName": null,
"Value": null
},
{
"CimType": 4,
"Flags": "None",
"Name": "error_Category",
"Qualifiers": [],
"ReferenceClassName": null,
"Value": 0
},
{
"CimType": 6,
"Flags": "None",
"Name": "error_Code",
"Qualifiers": [],
"ReferenceClassName": null,
"Value": 0
},
{
"CimType": 14,
"Flags": "None",
"Name": "error_Type",
"Qualifiers": [],
"ReferenceClassName": null,
"Value": null
},
{
"CimType": 14,
"Flags": "None",
"Name": "error_WindowsErrorMessage",
"Qualifiers": [],
"ReferenceClassName": null,
"Value": null
},
{
"CimType": 14,
"Flags": "None",
"Name": "ErrorSource",
"Qualifiers": [],
"ReferenceClassName": null,
"Value": null
},
{
"CimType": 4,
"Flags": "None",
"Name": "ErrorSourceFormat",
"Qualifiers": [],
"ReferenceClassName": null,
"Value": 0
},
{
"CimType": 4,
"Flags": "None",
"Name": "ErrorType",
"Qualifiers": [],
"ReferenceClassName": null,
"Value": 0
},
{
"CimType": 14,
"Flags": "None",
"Name": "Message",
"Qualifiers": [],
"ReferenceClassName": null,
"Value": null
},
{
"CimType": 14,
"Flags": "None",
"Name": "MessageID",
"Qualifiers": [],
"ReferenceClassName": null,
"Value": null
},
{
"CimType": 14,
"Flags": "None",
"Name": "OtherErrorSourceFormat",
"Qualifiers": [],
"ReferenceClassName": null,
"Value": null
},
{
"CimType": 14,
"Flags": "None",
"Name": "OtherErrorType",
"Qualifiers": [],
"ReferenceClassName": null,
"Value": null
},
{
"CimType": 14,
"Flags": "None",
"Name": "OWningEntity",
"Qualifiers": [],
"ReferenceClassName": null,
"Value": null
},
{
"CimType": 4,
"Flags": "None",
"Name": "PerceivedSeverity",
"Qualifiers": [],
"ReferenceClassName": null,
"Value": 0
},
{
"CimType": 4,
"Flags": "None",
"Name": "ProbableCause",
"Qualifiers": [],
"ReferenceClassName": null,
"Value": 0
},
{
"CimType": 14,
"Flags": "None",
"Name": "ProbableCauseDescription",
"Qualifiers": [],
"ReferenceClassName": null,
"Value": null
}
],
"CimClassQualifiers": [],
"CimSuperClass": null,
"CimSuperClassName": null,
"CimSystemProperties": {
"ClassName": "MSFT_WmiError",
"Namespace": "root/Microsoft/Windows/DesiredStateConfiguration",
"Path": null,
"ServerName": "localhost"
}
},
"CimInstanceProperties": [
{
"CimType": 6,
"Flags": "NotModified",
"IsValueModified": false,
"Name": "CIMStatusCode",
"Value": 5
},
{
"CimType": 14,
"Flags": "NotModified, NullValue",
"IsValueModified": false,
"Name": "CIMStatusCodeDescription",
"Value": null
},
{
"CimType": 4,
"Flags": "NotModified",
"IsValueModified": false,
"Name": "error_Category",
"Value": 5
},
{
"CimType": 6,
"Flags": "NotModified",
"IsValueModified": false,
"Name": "error_Code",
"Value": 5
},
{
"CimType": 14,
"Flags": "NotModified",
"IsValueModified": false,
"Name": "error_Type",
"Value": "MI"
},
{
"CimType": 14,
"Flags": "NotModified",
"IsValueModified": false,
"Name": "error_WindowsErrorMessage",
"Value": "The specified Class does not exist."
},
{
"CimType": 14,
"Flags": "NotModified",
"IsValueModified": false,
"Name": "ErrorSource",
"Value": ""
},
{
"CimType": 4,
"Flags": "NotModified, NullValue",
"IsValueModified": false,
"Name": "ErrorSourceFormat",
"Value": null
},
{
"CimType": 4,
"Flags": "NotModified, NullValue",
"IsValueModified": false,
"Name": "ErrorType",
"Value": null
},
{
"CimType": 14,
"Flags": "NotModified",
"IsValueModified": false,
"Name": "Message",
"Value": "Parameter set cannot be resolved using the specified named parameters."
},
{
"CimType": 14,
"Flags": "NotModified",
"IsValueModified": false,
"Name": "MessageID",
"Value": "AmbiguousParameterSet,Set-NetFirewallRule"
},
{
"CimType": 14,
"Flags": "NotModified, NullValue",
"IsValueModified": false,
"Name": "OtherErrorSourceFormat",
"Value": null
},
{
"CimType": 14,
"Flags": "NotModified, NullValue",
"IsValueModified": false,
"Name": "OtherErrorType",
"Value": null
},
{
"CimType": 14,
"Flags": "NotModified, NullValue",
"IsValueModified": false,
"Name": "OWningEntity",
"Value": null
},
{
"CimType": 4,
"Flags": "NotModified, NullValue",
"IsValueModified": false,
"Name": "PerceivedSeverity",
"Value": null
},
{
"CimType": 4,
"Flags": "NotModified, NullValue",
"IsValueModified": false,
"Name": "ProbableCause",
"Value": null
},
{
"CimType": 14,
"Flags": "NotModified, NullValue",
"IsValueModified": false,
"Name": "ProbableCauseDescription",
"Value": null
}
],
"CimSystemProperties": {
"ClassName": "MSFT_WmiError",
"Namespace": "root/Microsoft/Windows/DesiredStateConfiguration",
"Path": null,
"ServerName": "localhost"
}
},Passing Objects/Properties"DSCConfigObject": {
"Name": "xFirewall",
"Property": {
"Description": "Allow RDP Sessions to the Host from Management Networks - Manged by Ansible",
"Direction": "Inbound",
"EdgeTraversalPolicy": "Block",
"Enabled": "True",
"Ensure": "Present",
"Group": "Ansible Managed",
"LocalPort": [
"3389"
],
"Profile": [
"Domain",
"Private"
],
"Program": "%SystemRoot%\\system32\\svchost.exe",
"Protocol": "TCP",
"RemoteAddress": [
"172.16.11.0/24",
"172.16.118.0/24",
"172.16.119.0/24"
],
"Service": "termservice",
"name": "Ansible - Allow RDP Sessions from Management Networks"
}
},
"Description": "Allow RDP Sessions to the Host from Management Networks - Manged by Ansible",
"Direction": "Inbound",
"EdgeTraversalPolicy": "Block",
"Enabled": "True",
"Ensure": "Present",
"Group": "Ansible Managed",
"LocalPort": 3389,
"Profile": "Domain, Private",
"Program": "%SystemRoot%\\system32\\svchost.exe",
"Protocol": "TCP",
"RemoteAddress": "172.16.11.0/24, 172.16.118.0/24,172.16.119.0/24",
"Service": "termservice",
"changed": true,
"failed": true,
"item_name": "Ansible - Allow RDP Sessions from Management Networks",
"resource_name": "xFirewall" |
|
Looks like same as #130 Until the Bug on Set-NetworkRule with Group Params get fixed, there should be an Ignore If Statement or something. |
|
This issue has been automatically marked as stale because it has not had activity from the community in the last 30 days. It will be closed if no further activity occurs within 10 days. If the issue is labelled with any of the work labels (e.g bug, enhancement, documentation, or tests) then the issue will not auto-close. |
stale
bot
added
the
stale
|
This issue has been automatically closed because it is has not had activity from the community in the last 40 days. |
johlju
removed
help wanted
9 tasks
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment
unable to create / modify a firewall rule and use the group property. Any usage of the this property on Windows Server 2016 node will result in runtime error when applying the configuration.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: