Skip to content

Commit c4bfc36

Browse files
committed
Add discussion of input files
1 parent 2ab9009 commit c4bfc36

File tree

2 files changed

+6
-1
lines changed

2 files changed

+6
-1
lines changed

paper/benchmarkset.pdf

254 Bytes
Binary file not shown.

paper/benchmarkset.tex

+6-1
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -391,7 +391,9 @@ \subsubsection{Cucurbiturils}
391391
For example, in SAMPL4, free energy methods yielded $R^2$ values from 0.1 to 0.8 and RMS errors of about 1.9 to 4.9 kcal/mol for the same set of CB7 cases~\cite{muddana_sampl4_2014}.
392392
This spread of results across rather similar methods highlights the need for shared benchmarks.
393393
Potential explanations include convergence difficulties, subtle methodological differences, and details of how the methods were applied.
394-
Until the origin of such discrepancies is clear, it is difficult to know how accurate our methods truly are.
394+
Until the origin of such discrepancies is clear, it is difficult to know how accurate our methods truly are.
395+
396+
To aid the adoption of these systems as benchmarks, input files for the CB7 systems proposed here are available in our GitHub repository.
395397

396398
\begingroup
397399
\squeezetable
@@ -579,6 +581,8 @@ \subsubsection{Gibb Deep Cavity Cavitands (GDCC)}
579581
It is worth noting that several groups using different computational approaches but the same force field and water model in SAMPL5 did not obtain identical binding free energies~\cite{yin_overview_2016, bosisio_blinded_2016, bhakat_resolving_2016}.
580582
Some of these issues were resolved in follow-up work~\cite{bhakat_resolving_2016}, bringing the methods into fairly good agreement for the majority of cases~\cite{yin_sampl5_2016, bosisio_blinded_2016}.
581583

584+
To aid the adoption of these systems as benchmarks, input files for the GDCC systems proposed here are available in our GitHub repository.
585+
582586
\subsection{Protein-ligand benchmarks: the T4 lysozyme model binding sites}
583587
\label{sec:t4}
584588
\begin{figure*}
@@ -913,6 +917,7 @@ \section{CONCLUSIONS AND OUTLOOK}
913917
Identifying and addressing failure cases and problems is critically important to advancing this technology, but failures can be harder to publish, and may even go unpublished, even though they serve a unique role in advancing the field.
914918
We therefore strongly encourage that such results be shared and welcomed by the research community.
915919
Potentially, the GitHub repository connected with this perpetual review paper could serve as a place to deposit input files and summary results of tests on these benchmark systems, with summary information perhaps being included in this work itself or topical sub-reviews within the same repository.
920+
Host-guest input files are now available there.
916921

917922
Here, we have proposed several benchmark systems for binding free energy calculations.
918923
These embody a subset of the key challenges facing the field, and we plan to expand the set as consensus emerges.

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)