-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 5
/
Lecture_04_Case_Studies.Rmd
152 lines (119 loc) · 8.95 KB
/
Lecture_04_Case_Studies.Rmd
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100
101
102
103
104
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
112
113
114
115
116
117
118
119
120
121
122
123
124
125
126
127
128
129
130
131
132
133
134
135
136
137
138
139
140
141
142
143
144
145
146
147
148
149
150
151
152
## Lecture 4: Decision Analysis Case Studies {#case_studies}
<!-- reference with [Decision Analysis Case Studies](#case_studies) -->
Welcome to lecture 4 of **Decision Analysis and Forecasting for Agricultural Development**. In this lecture we will follow three case studies and use the `#lecture-04-case-studies` Slack channel and Zoom meeting to follow up. This will allow us all to have a chance to see your progress, provide feedback. As always, your engagement and sharing is appreciated. It will be encouraging to others to see activity from colleagues. Feel free to bring up any questions or concerns in the Slack or to [Dr. Cory Whitney](mailto:cory.whitney@uni-bonn.de?subject=[Seminar_2]%20Decision%20Analysis%20Lecture) or the course tutor.
Please take a few minutes to watch these short videos and do the associated exercises before our meeting.
### Introduction
The following videos introduce some decision analysis case studies. Please watch the videos and answer the questions that follow.
### Decision analysis case - Water for Wajir
The city of Wajir in Northern Kenya has lacks a reliable supply of clean drinking water and sanitation. To improve the situation, plans are being considered to construct a water pipeline from Habaswein over 100 km away [@luedeling_water_2014; @luedeling_fresh_2015]. Watch the following video to learn more.
<iframe width="560" height="315" src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/imQ1Gn-E7wQ" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>
Now try to answer the following questions:
```{r question-1-Decision-analysis-case-Water-for-Wajir, echo=FALSE}
question("What was the purpose of the inception workshop?",
answer("Elicit information about specific variables"),
answer("Secure political buy-in", correct = TRUE),
answer("Develop a conceptual model of the decision"),
answer("Allow stakeholders to state their expectations of the project", correct = TRUE),
incorrect = "Watch [the video](https://youtu.be/imQ1Gn-E7wQ) and try again.",
allow_retry = TRUE
)
```
```{r question-2-Decision-analysis-case-Water-for-Wajir, echo=FALSE}
question("What impacts are likely to arise from the freshwater pipeline?",
answer("Improved sanitation and public health in Wajir", correct = TRUE),
answer("Irrigated agriculture in Wajir"),
answer("Acceleration of economic development in Wajir", correct = TRUE),
answer("Free water supply for residents of Wajir"),
incorrect = "Watch [the video](https://youtu.be/imQ1Gn-E7wQ) and try again.",
allow_retry = TRUE
)
```
```{r question-3-Decision-analysis-case-Water-for-Wajir, echo=FALSE}
question("What are good strategies in consolidating range estimates by different people?",
answer("Average lower and upper bounds of intervals across all participants"),
answer("For outliers, find out if experts understood the question correctly", correct = TRUE),
answer("Consider which experts have are most knowledgeable on each estimated variable", correct = TRUE),
answer("Consider each expert's performance in previous estimation exercises", correct = TRUE),
incorrect = "Watch [the video](https://youtu.be/imQ1Gn-E7wQ) and try again.",
allow_retry = TRUE
)
```
### Case study - Plastic covers in sweet cherry orchards in Chile
This video shows the study @rojas_adapting_2021 conducted in Chile for assessing the profitability of implementing plastic covers in sweet cherry orchards to protect the fruits from hazardous weather events.
<!-- ![]() syntax will also work but not in html -->
<iframe width="560" height="315" src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/kpsqzkeg53Y" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>
```{r question-sweet_cherry-1, echo=FALSE}
question("How did the decision of implementing covers in sweet cherry orchards emerge in this study?",
answer("From a thorough literature review."),
answer("Based on the previous knowledge of the researchers."),
answer("From farmers' concerns regarding future weather scenarios.", correct = TRUE),
answer("From consumers asking for sweet cherries of good quality."),
incorrect = "Watch [the video](https://youtu.be/kpsqzkeg53Y) and try again.",
allow_retry = TRUE)
```
Based on the question above, think about and write down two to three positive and negative implications of using the method we used to define the decision.
```{r question-sweet_cherry-2, echo=FALSE}
question("Based on the Net Present Value, what would be the best recommendation for farmers in northern Chile?",
answer("Farmers should implement covers to improve yields."),
answer("NPV values suggest that implementing covers in northern Chile may be not necessary.", correct = TRUE),
answer("The results do not allow making a clear recomendation."),
incorrect = "Watch [the video](https://youtu.be/kpsqzkeg53Y) and try again.",
allow_retry = TRUE)
```
```{r questio-sweet_cherry-3, echo=FALSE}
question("Considering the results of the EVPI analysis, farmers should spend more resources to gather additional information on:",
answer("Yield"),
answer("Market price"),
answer("Yield lost to low firmness", correct = TRUE),
incorrect = "Watch [the video](https://youtu.be/kpsqzkeg53Y) and try again.",
allow_retry = TRUE)
```
The data and scripts for this study are also available online [@fernandez_data_2021].
### Group discussion reading:
- Luedeling, Eike, and Keith Shepherd. “[Decision-Focused Agricultural Research](https://www.thesolutionsjournal.com/article/decision-focused-agricultural-research/).” Solutions 7, no. 5 (2016): 46–54.
<!-- ### Bonus: Decision analysis case - Calluna production in NRW -->
<!-- Heather growers and other stakeholders in North Rhine-Westphalia, Germany are looking for sustainable options to manage disease outbreaks. @ruett_model-based_2020 worked with these farmers to model the impacts of changing disease management practices and to generate comprehensive forecasts of net returns. Watch the following video to learn more. -->
<!--  -->
<!-- <iframe width="560" height="315" src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/hvnhjrf1Ims" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe> -->
<!-- Think about the following questions and jot down your thoughts. -->
<!-- - **How would you develop an expert network for your decision analysis project?** -->
<!-- - **What do you expect from your expert network?** -->
<!-- [](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hvnhjrf1Ims) -->
<!-- ```{r Question1-Calluna, echo=FALSE} -->
<!-- question("What are the risks and uncertainties in Calluna production?", -->
<!-- answer("Bud-flowering mutation"), -->
<!-- answer("Water management", correct = TRUE), -->
<!-- answer("Fungal infections", correct = TRUE), -->
<!-- answer("Fertilizer management", correct = TRUE), -->
<!-- answer("Customer demand"), -->
<!-- answer("Fungal resistance to pesticides", correct = TRUE), -->
<!-- incorrect = "Watch [the video](https://youtu.be/hvnhjrf1Ims) and try again.", -->
<!-- allow_retry = TRUE -->
<!-- ) -->
<!-- ``` -->
<!-- ```{r Question2-Calluna, echo=FALSE} -->
<!-- question("What steps did we use to apply decision analysis in Calluna production?", -->
<!-- answer("Developing impact models", correct = TRUE), -->
<!-- answer("Defining decisions together with experts using participatory workshops", correct = TRUE), -->
<!-- answer("Using precise numbers instead of ranges"), -->
<!-- answer("Calibration of experts", correct = TRUE), -->
<!-- answer("Involving the local government"), -->
<!-- answer("Using model simulations to calculate probability distributions, VIP scores and the EVPI", correct = TRUE), -->
<!-- incorrect = "Watch [the video](https://youtu.be/hvnhjrf1Ims) and try again.", -->
<!-- allow_retry = TRUE -->
<!-- ) -->
<!-- ``` -->
<!-- ```{r Question3-Calluna, echo=FALSE} -->
<!-- question("How can we overcome the tendency of experts to make mistakes when generating estimates and making judgements?", -->
<!-- answer("Confront the participants from your expert network with their biases", correct = TRUE), -->
<!-- answer("Teach techniques that allow your participants to give better estimations (Calibration training)", correct = TRUE), -->
<!-- answer("Apply techniques that allow both shy and confident participants to contribute to your decision analysis workshop", correct = TRUE), -->
<!-- answer("Involve as many professors as possible"), -->
<!-- answer("Experts in high job positions would do better estimations than Master students"), -->
<!-- answer("Apply techniques that allow you to focus more detailed on certain findings instead of focusing on the whole picture"), -->
<!-- answer("Use feedback from all participants to merge all models into a model that you can use as a template to program your code", correct = TRUE), -->
<!-- incorrect = "Watch [the video](https://youtu.be/hvnhjrf1Ims) and try again.", -->
<!-- allow_retry = TRUE -->
<!-- ) -->
<!-- ``` -->
<!-- The data and scripts for this study are available in this [zenodo repository]( http://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.4637259) [@ruett_data_2021]. -->